In-depth reviews

Audi R8 review – living with one

evo editor Stuart Gallagher had the tough job of finding out what six months of Audi R8 Performance ownership was like...

Evo rating
  • Superb powertrain, approachable handing, excellent build quality and even practical for a mid-engined supercar
  • Steering still not perfect, lacks the clarity and edge found in some rivals

I never did make 12,000 miles in evo’s R8 Performance Carbon Black, falling 11 miles short for no other reason than Audi wanted its supercar back and I couldn’t face covering another 11 miles in central London on the day it returned. But being the custodian of a 611bhp mid-engined V10 supercar for the best part of a year was never a hardship, every one of those miles making you feel you were in something special. 

We made the call to run the Performance over the regular 562bhp R8 prior to the latter finishing on the top step of the podium in our Porsche 992 Carrera group test (issue 261). This wasn’t the first time the R8 has claimed a 911 scalp, but perception is that the Porsche is unbeatable and all others are runners up – before, during and after any such test. For the R8 to come out on top, while unexpected, was roundly deserved. ‘In boxing parlance the R8 wins on a narrow majority decision rather than a knockout blow,’ concluded Dickie Meaden, the referee of said test. 

Where that group test-winning R8 and our R8 Performance differed was under the aluminium skin, and not just in power output, for our car was fitted with the £1350 Dynamic Steering option, which in the past has caused a few issues for evo with fast Audis (and Lamborghinis). One thing this long-term test proved was that these systems are constantly evolving, and more often than not for the better. Helped by Audi Sport not chasing a super-alert and hyper-sensitive rate of response, the R8’s steering was always consistent and linear on the road. Feel wasn’t great and more weight wouldn’t have gone amiss, especially in lower-speed turns when it would often feel as if the front tyres were floating over the surface rather than clawing at the tarmac. A combination of low tyre temperatures and cold mornings could exacerbate this sensation, making those front Michelins feel overinflated such was the lack of resistance during the first degrees of lock.

But generally speaking, on the road the latest Dynamic Steering was a considerable step in the right direction compared to previous iterations. However, on track it still left you wanting more: precision, feel and feedback primarily, and there were times you found yourself more in tune with the car’s rear axle than its front. Which was a little strange, but could be resolved to some extent with some tyre pressure tweaking.

With optimal temperatures and pressures, however, the R8 was everything you would expect and hope a car of its ilk to be on the road. That enigmatic V10 engine was capable of producing violent performance, and you’ll be pleased to hear that it was at its least impressive when pressed into mundane drives such as airport runs and city commuting. Yes, it could do it, but it felt like you had selected the biggest hammer to drive the smallest tack through the softest wall of plaster. It was when the opportunity arose to dial the engine up to Dynamic or Performance mode that it delivered its exhilarating all. McLaren’s turbocharged V8s feel stronger, punchier and more powerful (probably because every car we test feels likes it has a minimum of 800bhp) but the cultured tones and measured delivery of the R8’s two banks of five naturally aspirated cylinders made for an engaging and rich experience few other engines can deliver. Balancing the R8 on the throttle as you glided through a series of corners, the engine in its sweet spot and ready to let rip the split-second your right foot squeezed the throttle to its stop was intoxicating. 

Combined with great balance and a body with a generous amount of lean to build against, the R8 remains a calmer supercar than many, but no less involving or rewarding. Crucially, it had that ‘early morning drive for the sake of it’ appeal.

Dynamic Steering wasn’t the only option fitted. £3150 provided LED headlights with laser full beams, and as winter kicked in these came into their own, the clarity of vision provided remarkable. On more than one occasion they saved one of the R8’s 20-inch Pilot Sport 4 S tyres from a terminal encounter with a pothole due to the surface definition they imparted. Cost options often look pricey during the ordering stage, but these lights were worth every penny. 

Less convincing was the £2500 charged for Alcantara headlining and the further £2900 for a full leather package. Shouldn’t these be standard on a car with a £154,100 retail price? However, the £250 storage bags fixed to the engine bulkhead behind the seats proved invaluable on a trip to the N24 with a photographer who doesn’t understand how to pack lightly. 

R8s have a bit of a bad rep amongst the supercar cognoscenti. Many can’t get beyond the badge, take a look at the price and head to more established makes and models. And I get that; not everyone wants their supercar to be an everyday all-rounder or have a three-door hatchback as a family member. But these people are missing out, because the R8 remains as credible today as it did back in 2007 when it first toppled the 911, and it still runs rings around its Lamborghini cousin.

Most Popular

MAT Stratos 2021 review – Lancia’s iconic Stratos reborn
MAT Stratos – front tracking
Lancia

MAT Stratos 2021 review – Lancia’s iconic Stratos reborn

It’s been a long time coming, but this Ferrari F430-based reimagining of the Lancia Stratos is finally here
11 Jun 2021
Tesla Model S Plaid deliveries begin – 1006bhp super saloon now reaching customers
Tesla Model S Plaid
Tesla Model S

Tesla Model S Plaid deliveries begin – 1006bhp super saloon now reaching customers

The long-awaited Tesla Model S Plaid has finally come to fruition, with first US examples hitting the road
11 Jun 2021
2021 Audi RS3 Sportback and saloon previewed – will it finally match Mercedes-AMG A45 S?
Audi RS3 manufacturer spy 1
Audi RS3

2021 Audi RS3 Sportback and saloon previewed – will it finally match Mercedes-AMG A45 S?

Audi Sport is putting the final touches on its new RS3 hot hatch and saloon
10 Jun 2021
2021 Maserati GranTurismo to go EV-only – IC option ditched
2021 Maserati GranTurismo spy – track
Maserati

2021 Maserati GranTurismo to go EV-only – IC option ditched

GranTurismo coupe and its soft-top GranCabrio sibling to be reborn later this year, but controversially without the proposed combustion alternative...…
11 Jun 2021
Posaidon’s 217mph Mercedes-AMG E63 RS is faster than a Porsche 918 Spyder
Posaidon Mercedes-AMG E63
Mercedes E63 AMG

Posaidon’s 217mph Mercedes-AMG E63 RS is faster than a Porsche 918 Spyder

Three new Posaidon power upgrades are now available for Mercedes-AMG’s E63 S, bringing hypercar numbers to the four door supersaloon
9 Jun 2021
Used car deals of the week
Used car deals 11 June 21
used cars

Used car deals of the week

Here's what caught evo’s fancy this week on the second hand car market
11 Jun 2021
Ford Mustang Steve McQueen Bullitt Edition 2021 review – a 720bhp tribute act
Ford Mustang Steve McQueen Bullitt Edition – slide
Ford Mustang

Ford Mustang Steve McQueen Bullitt Edition 2021 review – a 720bhp tribute act

Immense performance from about the coolest modern muscle car out there. It’s expensive, but there’s nothing else quite like it
12 Jun 2021
Cheap fast cars 2021 – the best budget performance cars on the market
Cheap fast cars 2021
used cars

Cheap fast cars 2021 – the best budget performance cars on the market

If you buy right and do your research, the cheap fast car is a wonderful thing. Here are our top picks between £1000 and £10,000
25 May 2021
Ferrari F8 Tributo replacement mule spied – will it emulate the McLaren Artura?
Ferrari F171 spy 2021 – front
Ferrari

Ferrari F8 Tributo replacement mule spied – will it emulate the McLaren Artura?

Ferrari’s going hybrid and V6 for its next mid-engined supercar
9 Jun 2021
HKS in development of a supercharger kit for new 2021 Toyota GR 86
HKS Toyota GR 86
Toyota

HKS in development of a supercharger kit for new 2021 Toyota GR 86

Japanese tuner HKS is in development of a supercharger upgrade package for the new GR 86
9 Jun 2021
Best small cars 2021 – pocket rockets reviewed and rated
Best small cars 2021
Best cars

Best small cars 2021 – pocket rockets reviewed and rated

You don’t need 200bhp or more in a small hatchback to have fun – these ‘warm’ small cars are the proof
7 Jun 2021
2021 Alpina XD3 and XD4 update revealed – extra torque from Alpine’s quad-turbo diesel SUV
Alpina XD3 and XD4 2021 – header
Alpina XD3

2021 Alpina XD3 and XD4 update revealed – extra torque from Alpine’s quad-turbo diesel SUV

The updates to the Alpina XD3 and XD4 are largely of the aesthetic kind, but more torque and new chassis calibrations are also part of the package
10 Jun 2021
2022 BMW X3 and X4 M Competition pricing announced
2022 BMW X3 and X4 M Competitions
BMW

2022 BMW X3 and X4 M Competition pricing announced

Engine upgrades, a chassis recalibration and some striking new visuals for BMW’s hot midsize SUVs
11 Jun 2021
Can the Renault Clio Trophy beat a modern supersaloon for daily transport?
Jethro opinion header
Opinion

Can the Renault Clio Trophy beat a modern supersaloon for daily transport?

The boot struts have gone saggy and the hatch slams onto my head three times a week, but the Clio Trophy is hard to resist
8 Jun 2021