Tesla Model S review – supercar-like acceleration for an electric luxury saloon

The Model S exudes the benefits an electric car has over fossil-fuelled alternatives; Supercharger network makes it more usable than ever

Evo rating
Price
from £79,980
  • Remarkable and addictive acceleration, low running costs
  • Regenerative brakes make it difficult to really connect with the car

We’ve been led to believe that the internal combustion engine is old-hat and that electric cars will be the future. Not that long ago, that would have been a dire and scary proposition, but electric cars have gone through a renaissance and now some are even becoming desirable. This change of reputation is, in part, thanks to Tesla and its venerable Model S; a premium, fast, and usable electric saloon car.

It’s been sold in various guises over the years with model names such as the P75 and P100D but in its latest incarnation there are two models to choose from; the standard dual-motor variant and the Plaid. Unfortunately, these newest editions – with their revamped interiors and improved performance – are only available in left-hand drive in the UK, which is a shame. 

> 200mph Tesla Model S Plaid set for 2021 launch

The Model S combines such incredible performance with an effortless driving experience making it an astoundingly effective machine for covering ground. With a maximum real world range between 373 and 394 miles (depending on which spec you choose) and an expanding network of supercharger points that allow the Model S to top up its battery in a remarkably short space of time, it's also one of the most usable electric cars on the market.

When it comes to pure thrills nothing else about the Model S can match its ability to accelerate (although we're yet to try the Nurburgring record-breaking Plaid equipped with the Track Package). That’s mostly because it’s such a remarkable party piece, but equally the Model S isn’t a car that comes alive in a corner or allows a driver to really get under its skin.

Tesla Model S in detail

  • Performance and 0-60 time - All models of the Tesla Model S can safely be described as brisk. Opt for the fastest Performance model and initial accelerative performance matches that of many hypercars.
  • Engine and gearbox - The Model S’s electric motors drive an axle each, ensuring both grunt and traction are superb.
  • Ride and handling - Despite a hefty kerbweight, the car’s centre of gravity is low helping the chassis stay composed. 
  • MPG and running costs - Its range is good enough for the vast majority of journeys and with no fuel costs the Model S can be a cheap car to run. 
  • Design - Some will say the Model S looks a little conservative, but we like that Tesla has avoided trying too hard. 

Prices, specs and rivals

Tesla has been quiet about Model S availability since the facelifted version was announced in 2021, and the silence was broken this year with the news that the car would no longer be offered in right-hand drive form. Pricing is somewhat of a mystery too, although we do know that the Plaid costs from £125,000, with the dual-motor version expected to undercut this considerably. You get sensational performance for your money, though, with the triple-motor Plaid hitting 60mph from rest in 1.99 seconds with a one-foot rollout. The Plaid's 373-mile range figure is impressive too, and the less powerful base car extends this by an extra 21 miles. For comparison, the range-topping Porsche Taycan Turbo S can achieve up to 291 miles. Dynamic ability, however, is where the Porsche really excels...

> New Porsche Taycan review - Stuttgart puts its stamp on the electric car era

Despite the Tesla’s hypercar-like performance, its high price makes it far from rival-free across its price spread. Alongside the aforementioned Porsche Taycan, the Tesla's chief competitors come in the form of the Mercedes EQE and BMW's recently announced i5. Neither can match the Tesla's blend of performance and range, though – in AMG EQE 53 guise, the Mercedes generates 616bhp and provides 280 miles of range, with BMW's flagship i5 M60 offering 593bhp and up to 320 miles from a single charge. Still, the numbers only tell part of the story, and the Tesla will need to stand up in terms of its dynamics and build quality to see off the competition.

If you’re drawn to the all-electric lifestyle but don’t quite have the cash to drop on a Model S, the Model 3 could well be the model for you, acting as a cheaper, more compact alternative.

More on Model S

First ever electric production car race series
Tesla P100D EPCS
Tesla Model S hatchback

First ever electric production car race series

The FIA endorsed new one-make Tesla race series, the Electric Production Car Series, will get underway this year
1 Feb 2018
Tesla Model S Shooting Brake takes to the the road
Tesla Model S Shooting Brake – side
Tesla Model S hatchback

Tesla Model S Shooting Brake takes to the the road

A specially-commissioned, Tesla Model S Shooting Brake is now on the road with claims on the ‘world’s fastest estate car’ title
30 Jan 2018
Tesla Model S P100D revealed
Tesla Model S hatchback

Tesla Model S P100D revealed

New Ludicrous Plus mode makes P100D even faster
12 Jan 2017
Tesla's 'master plan' - solar, trucks, autonomy and more
Tesla Model 3 twin
Tesla Model S hatchback

Tesla's 'master plan' - solar, trucks, autonomy and more

The next few years of Tesla Motors are laid out - including solar power, public transport and even autonomous car sharing
21 Jul 2016
Voltes styling upgrades for Tesla Model S
Tesla Model S hatchback

Voltes styling upgrades for Tesla Model S

Modifications from American and German companies will now be imported into the UK
15 Jul 2016
Authorities investigating first autonomous Tesla fatality
Tesla Model S hatchback

Authorities investigating first autonomous Tesla fatality

Fatality is first in 130 million autonomous miles - but is sure to prompt concerns about the abilities of such systems
1 Jul 2016
New entry-level Tesla Model S 60 announced
Tesla Model S hatchback

New entry-level Tesla Model S 60 announced

Wi-Fi update can bring more performance
9 Jun 2016
Tesla Model S the basis of new all-electric GT race series
Tesla Model S hatchback

Tesla Model S the basis of new all-electric GT race series

Electric GT World Series scheduled for 2017 start; Tesla's EV the exclusive car choice until other manufacturers join
11 Mar 2016
Tesla Autopilot self-driving software launched
tech
Tesla Model S hatchback

Tesla Autopilot self-driving software launched

CEO Elon Musk presents his vision of an autonomous driving future, but still sees a future for real driving too
14 Oct 2015
Hands-on with Tesla's Model S infotainment screen
tesla
Tesla Model S hatchback

Hands-on with Tesla's Model S infotainment screen

Is the huge infotainment screen in Tesla's Model S distracting? We find out
10 Sep 2015
Tesla reveals faster Model S, Model X, new Roadster
Tesla Model S hatchback

Tesla reveals faster Model S, Model X, new Roadster

Two core Tesla models will offer class-leading performance, and there’s a new Roadster on the horizon too
17 Jul 2015
Tesla announces new entry level Model S 70D saloon
Tesla Model S hatchback

Tesla announces new entry level Model S 70D saloon

More affordable Model S, yet still very fast, available now
10 Apr 2015
Tesla Easter egg turns car icon into Lotus Esprit sub
Tesla Model S hatchback

Tesla Easter egg turns car icon into Lotus Esprit sub

Hidden feature turns instrumentation 007
27 Feb 2015
Tesla Model S - Your questions answered
Tesla Model S hatchback

Tesla Model S - Your questions answered

We answer your Facebook questions on the Tesla Model S
14 Jan 2015