Skip advert
Advertisement
Long term tests

Lotus Elise S1

It's been a frustrating summer of service hell for Brett Fraser and his ageing S1

Were fate a kinder bedfellow, I’d have spent our glorious summer making whoopee in my Elise. Instead I’ve spent most of the dry season knocking about in other cars while amassing sufficient funds to pay for all the work that my chums in the Lotus factory service workshops were doing to R167 CUA to make it roadworthy again.

Advertisement - Article continues below

I’d dropped the Elise in with the affable Glenn Smith and his merry serviceers for what I imagined would be a straightforward minor service prior to a trip to this year’s Le Mans. A bit later in the day came the first phone call indicating that a few little extras might be required: a new exhaust back-box, steering rack gaiter, replacement bolts for some of those that hold the undertray in place, and other sundries.

That phone call seemed depressing enough and immediately put the Le Mans trip in doubt as some of the parts weren’t off-the-shelf items. The next call had me eyeing up tall buildings from which to jump; while being run on the rolling road, the Elise had popped off some of its hoses and the leaking coolant had an ominously milky complexion indicating at best a head gasket failure, at worst a dropped cylinder liner. ‘Oh, and by the way, the reason that the coolant had needed topping up so frequently is that the car needs a new radiator, and you might want to sort out some new tyres if you want it to go cleanly through the MOT that’s now due.’ Glenn must have been hoping that, as the messenger, he wasn’t now sitting in my rifle’s crosshairs.

Advertisement - Article continues below
Skip advert
Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

He kindly agreed to prolong the work as long as possible so that I could get my finances in order. Meanwhile I discovered that Lotus now recommends the Yokohama C.drive as a replacement for the original-spec Pirellis, which are no longer made. Lots of people fit wider-than-standard track-biased Yokos to their Elises, me included, so it’ll be interesting to see what a difference narrower, road-only rubber will make.

With all the work done, my Elise is unsurprisingly running better than ever (and sounds great with its new sports exhaust), so I’m praying for this Indian summer to continue, to compensate for the good weather I missed out on.

But anyone tempted by a cheap Elise S1 – and they’re down to as little as £7500 these days – should learn a lesson from my tale of woe. Get your potential purchase checked over by an expert because lots of things wear out on the Elise and to replace them can cost a fortune, as I’ve discovered. Replacing the head gasket, for instance, means dropping the engine out and also involves a new cam timing belt. I wouldn’t want to put you off, but I do advise caution. Right now, though, with my Elise restored to full health, there’s no other car I’d rather have.

Running Costs

Date acquiredSeptember 2002
Total mileage63,175
Costs this month£3048 (servicing and repairs), £286 (tyres)
Mileage this month313
MPG this month33.1mpg
Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

Best car tyres 2026 – evo tyre test
evo tyre test 2026
Features

Best car tyres 2026 – evo tyre test

What are the best road tyres for your hot hatch? We tested and ranked nine of them
18 Oct 2026
No, you can’t drive the ‘flying’ Tesla Roadster on the road, or buy one…
2028 Tesla Roadster
News

No, you can’t drive the ‘flying’ Tesla Roadster on the road, or buy one…

The demo for the revived Tesla Roadster was certainly awe inspiring, but don’t start planning your flight routes to work just yet
16 Oct 2026
New Mercedes-AMG GT SUV is a 1153bhp alternative to the Porsche Cayenne Electric
Mercedes-AMG GT SUV
News

New Mercedes-AMG GT SUV is a 1153bhp alternative to the Porsche Cayenne Electric

Joining the AMG GT 4-door electric is a new SUV, with a tri-motor set-up, over 1100bhp and hypercar performance. The question is: will it sell?
17 Oct 2026