Skip advert
Advertisement

The truth about tyre labelling - can you really trust them?

Tyre makers grade their own products, so what's stopping them from cheating?

You might be surprised to learn that while tyre grading labels are now mandatory in the EU, there’s no independent body to verify them. Instead, it’s down to the tyre manufacturers themselves to grade their own products, so does this leave the door open for made-up ratings?

‘It wouldn’t be possible for premium brands to just make ratings up – they all test each other’s tyres so someone would notice,’ says Jonathan Benson, a tyre expert who runs tyrereviews.co.uk.

Advertisement - Article continues below

‘But that’s not to say they don’t know how to get the best out of the label criteria. Water depth, surface temperature and co-efficient of grip can all be modified within allowed parameters, which the companies with the biggest budgets will be taking advantage of.’

The real issue with tyre labels is that they only reveal a small part of a tyre’s performance. ‘Someone might look at a budget tyre and see that it’s only one grade away from a premium in wet performance,’ says Benson. ‘They might then think it’s a bargain. But that tyre will likely be worse in several other areas. The next generation of the label needs to at least include wear. Wet grip and wear are contrasting qualities; it’s difficult to score well in both criteria.'

So what can we do to ensure that we buy the right set of tyres? Benson explains: ‘Keep looking at magazine tests and independent tyre reviews. Unlike the labels, they’re testing all round performance and not just a very narrow window of it.’ You can find the results to the 2015 evo Tyre Test here.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

Hyundai i30 N Fast Fleet test – 8 months with the Korean hot hatch
Hyundai i30 N evo Fast Fleet
Long term tests

Hyundai i30 N Fast Fleet test – 8 months with the Korean hot hatch

The i30 N has been one of our favourite hot hatches ever since we first sampled it. It passed the long-term test with flying colours, too
9 Apr 2024
BMW M3 CS v Alfa Romeo Giulia GTA v Jaguar XE Project 8 – supersaloon specials go head-to-head
BMW M3 CS v Alfa Romeo Giulia GTA v Jaguar XE Project 8
Group tests

BMW M3 CS v Alfa Romeo Giulia GTA v Jaguar XE Project 8 – supersaloon specials go head-to-head

BMW’s M3 CS is so dazzlingly good that a regular head-to-head seemed inadequate. Instead we pit it against two icons, Alfa Romeo’s sublime Giulia GTA …
7 Apr 2024
The new Audi S3 gets more power and RS3 tech
2024 Audi S3
News

The new Audi S3 gets more power and RS3 tech

Audi’s middling S3 hot hatch has been given an update for the 2024 model year, gaining powertrain tweaks, a design update and the RS3’s torque-splitti…
8 Apr 2024