BMW M4 vs BMW M5 - evo Deadly Rivals

Two German giants battle it out to find the true 'thrill of driving'

BMW's M division has made some truly fantastic cars. The latest crop, the BMW M4 and M5, represent the absolute pinnacle of what can be done with a saloon car right now.

As part of a new series on evo.co.uk road test editor Dan Prosser will be pitting the very best of performance cars up against each other. Called Deadly Rivals, the first sees BMW's M5 defend its crown against its little brother, the M4.

Specifications

BMW M4

Engine2979cc, inline six, twin turbo
Power424 bhp
Torque406 lb ft
0-60mph4.3 sec
Top Speed155 mph
MPG34 mpg
Lap time1:04.39

BMW M5 - 30 Jahre Edition

Engine4395cc, V8, twin turbo
Power592 bhp
Torque516 lb ft
0-60mph3.9 sec
Top Speed155 mph
MPG28 mpg
Lap Time1:04.65

Test notes

BMW M4

Logic suggests that the M4 will destroy the M5 on circuit because it's so much lighter and so much more agile. That said, there are two really long straights at Bedford Autodrome south circuit and the M5 has more power.

Even so, the M4 is incredibly quick. If the M5 is going to keep up it's going to have to be mighty under braking.

One of the issues we have with the M4 is that it can lose some body control at times, but then at others it can be extremely balanced. At high speed cornering, the M4 excels. It settles and grips and is extremely stable.

Braking performance is also stellar. You can brake later than you think is possible and after the long home straight the M4 can really scrub speed off right at the last minute.

The gearbox in the M4 and M5 is the same DCT unit. It's superb on track shifting as quick as you could ever want it to and letting you focus on lines as much as need be.

BMW M5 - 30 Jahre Edition

The M5 is actually remarkably good on track given that it’s not just a track car in the slightest and with a full tank of fuel and road test editor Dan Prosser onboard it weighs 2 tons.

Down the straights it's lightning quick, with almost 200bhp more than the M4. That said, it also shows its weight and feels bigger and heavier. 3 laps were all it took to really start cooking the brakes.

All that speed means you have to over brake the car a lot more as you've just got more to take off after the long straights.

Turn in and the front end of the M4 is its real strong point. The M5 struggles here a lot more. It also can't hold a line in the same way that the M4 can, which means corner exit phase requires you to be a lot more patient before getting on the power.

Ultimately though, the power is what makes the M5 stay so close to the M4 in lap times. It loses out under braking and turn in speed but makes it all back on the straights. Despite the big weight increase, the M5's powertrain means it can deliver a lap time  incredibly close to what the M4 manages.

Winner

In the end, the M4's brilliant front end, ample power and excellent brakes and gearbox all mean it delivers an experience that just bests the M5.

What is worth mentioning however is just how suprised we were by the M5. It was much more exciting to drive on track than we expected and the powertrain continues to be one of the very best.

Recommended

BMW M4 mule with aero mods caught in testing
BMW M4 CS prototype 2021 - rear
BMW M4 coupe

BMW M4 mule with aero mods caught in testing

Could a BMW M4 CS, or perhaps even a new CSL, already be in the works?
12 Apr 2021
BMW M4 Competition 2021 review – a super coupe sensation
BMW M4 Competition 2021 review – front tracking
BMW M4 coupe

BMW M4 Competition 2021 review – a super coupe sensation

BMW's long-awaited M4 Competition doesn't hold back any punches. It's fast, immensely capable, but also superb fun
9 Mar 2021
Limited-run BMW M4 Competition x Kith revealed
BMW M4 coupe

Limited-run BMW M4 Competition x Kith revealed

BMW has partnered with American fashion brand Kith to create a limited-run M4 Competition
27 Oct 2020
BMW M4 review
BMW M4 coupe

BMW M4 review

In the face of talented rivals, the M4 remains a solid, sophisticated option for keen drivers
7 Oct 2020

Most Popular

BMW X5 M Competition 2021 review – how does the M division’s biggest SUV stack up?
Crop X5 M Competition
BMW X5 M

BMW X5 M Competition 2021 review – how does the M division’s biggest SUV stack up?

In many ways critically flawed, but there is something oddly captivating about its unerring focus
7 May 2021
Mandatory speed limiters to be fitted to all new UK cars after 2022
80mph motorway speed limit
News

Mandatory speed limiters to be fitted to all new UK cars after 2022

The use of mandatory speed limiters and data loggers on all new cars has been approved by the European Parliament, and manufacturers are already makin…
28 Apr 2021
Audi RS6 v Porsche Panamera Sport Turismo v Mercedes-AMG E63 S Estate – super-estates go head-to-head
Audi RS6 v Porsche Panamera v Mercedes-AMG
Features

Audi RS6 v Porsche Panamera Sport Turismo v Mercedes-AMG E63 S Estate – super-estates go head-to-head

Which 600bhp wagon is the current super-estate king? It‘s time to find out as the Audi RS6 Avant takes on Porsche Panamera Turbo S E-Hybrid Sport Turi…
8 May 2021