BMW M4 review – has BMW honed the M4 into a class leader?

In the face of talented rivals, the M4 remains a solid, sophisticated option for keen drivers

Evo rating
from £62,300
  • Serious straight line performance, styling, dry-weather handling
  • Very tricky in the wet and over challenging roads

This is BMW’s first M4, the result of a convoluted new naming strategy it has employed across its model range, but be in no illusion that in the saloon-based performance coupe sphere, BMW doesn’t only know how to play the game, it pretty much created it.

So when BMW launched the M4 back in 2014, its mixed reception didn’t so much come as a surprise, but rather bewilderment about what could have possibly gone wrong. Since then, the M4 (and its four-door M3 sibling) has undergone multiple revisions, as well as been diversified into the excellent, but eye-wateringly expensive CS and lesser Competition Pack options.

Subscribe to evo magazine

Subscribe today to have every issue of evo delivered straight to you. You'll SAVE 39% on the shop price, and get evo for its original cover price for a whole year!

> Click here for our latest review of the Alfa Romeo Giulia QV

Equipped with the same 3-litre twin turbocharged straight-six from its initial launch, the M4’s speed has never been in doubt, but has BMW been able to reintegrate the finesse which helped define its illustrious forbears? There is no quick way to describe how the M4 drives – suffice to say it could never be described as dull or benign.

The M4's complicated reception has not only been affected by its reputation either, because where previous M3s largely had their corner of the market to themselves, the M4 most certainly doesn’t, with the charismatic Mercedes-AMG C 63, Alfa Romeo Giulia QV and Audi RS5 all raising their game for class honours. 

So does the M4 still deserve its place at the top of its mount, or has the king been dethroned? Read on to find out.

BMW M4 in detail

  • > Performance and 0-60 time - The  M4 matches the performance of supercars from not long ago, hitting 62mph in 4.1sec and reaching 155mph. The most impressive figure, however, is a 0-100mph time of 8.6sec.
  • > Engine and gearbox - The 3-litre, twin-turbocharged straight-six develops 425bhp, but the real drama comes from the new engine’s torque, which peaks at 406lb ft from just 1850rpm.
  • > Ride and handling - The new M4 is lighter than the coupe it replaces and as a result feels more alert and agile. However, the steering is now electrically, not hydraulically, assisted, so some feel has been lost.
  • > MPG and running costs - Now with a turbocharged engine, the M4 is substantially more frugal than before, and BMW quotes a combined 34.4mpg. 
  • > Interior and tech - The M4's relative age comes through in the interior, but quality and tech can't be argued with.
  • > Design - The M4 stands out from the regular 4-series with a ‘powerdome’ bonnet, swollen wheelarches, deep air intakes and, the now obligatory for an M-car, quad-tailpipes.
  • > BMW M4 vs rivals - evo 240 saw the BMW M4 Competition Pack meet the Audi RS5 and Mercedes-AMG C63 in an evo Supertest.
  • > Video review - See the M4 pitted against an M5 then a Porsche 911 Carrera. Watch our BMW M4 video review here


Prices, specs and rivals

Prices for the non-Competition M4 start from £62,300 for the coupe, rising to £66,520 for the convertible. Should you be heavy-handed with options though, prices can easily exceed £70,000 for both; carbon ceramic brakes alone add £6250, for example, while adaptive LED headlights cost £1200. The Competition Package adds another £3000 over the standard car.

If you're looking to buy an M4, you might have been advised to opt for the £2695 DCT automatic gearbox purely for residual value. We're not so sure ditching the standard-fit manual is a wise move, though, nor do we think it will necessarily help with resale value.

Move up from the standard and Competition Pack variants and you'll find the £89,130 M4 CS, a car that replaces the extreme GTS as the range-topping model. Though it's not limited in numbers like the M4 GTS, the M4 CS is harder to source than the standard car. Under the skin, Munich's finest engineers fettle the coupe to be the best driving machine possible, whilst retaining the ability to drive it everyday, unlike the hardcore GTS. 

> Click here to read more about the BMW M4 DTM Champion Edition

The price and performance of the M4 put it squarely in line with the likes of the new C63 AMG, Audi RS5 and the Lexus RC-F. Arguably, the M4 is a different ownership proposition to all of them, being a more raw and hard-edged car. But these M-cars lack some of the drama that their rivals offer.

Plenty of track testing with the M4 reveal that the carbon ceramic brakes are fantastic, but perhaps not an option worth ticking unless you intend on driving the M4 frequently on track.

In pure specs terms however, the M4's standard offering perhaps bests its rivals. iDrive remains one of the best in-car entertainment systems you can get, while the special M-Sport seats are nice to look at and fantastically supportive and comfortable.

> Read our C63 AMG review

Alfa hasn't pulled any punches with its new Giulia. The Quadrifoglio comes with a carbonfibre prop shaft, torque vectoring, adaptive dampers, a carbonfibre bonnet and front splitter, as well as optional carbon ceramic brakes. The Alfa Romeo's interior looks special, even if it doesn’t feel very premium. There are several touches clearly lifted out of the Ferrari rule book, including big aluminium shift paddles and an engine start button on the wheel.

To drive, the Giulia feels progressive and engaging, while the engine remains exciting right the way to its 7000rpm redline. It also puts out a sound that's easily on par with the M4, but not quite a match for the C63's turbocharged V8.

More on M4 coupe

BMW M4 coupe

BMW Motorsport details Zanardi’s amazing hand-controlled M4 DTM

Zanardi's latest BMW M4 DTM racer ditches the pedal box entirely
7 Aug 2018
BMW M4 coupe

BMW M4 CS review - the best M4 money can buy?

Not as extreme as the GTS but more focused than the standard car, the BMW M4 CS is the most amenable and exploitable M4 yet.
27 Feb 2018
BMW M4 coupe

BMW M4 Convertible Edition 30 Jahre revealed

The new BMW M4 Convertible Edition 30 Jahre gains a bespoke colour palette, but no extra power
20 Feb 2018
BMW M4 coupe

New BMW M4 CS revealed – motorsport-inspired tweaks for straight-six super-coupe

An engine tune, styling tweaks and altered suspension mean the CS sits between the standard M4 and the GTS
19 Apr 2017
BMW M4 coupe

2017 DTM preview – New regulations promise to make the new season truly entertaining

More power, less downforce means the 2017 DTM cars could be tricky to drive, but great to watch
31 Mar 2017
BMW M4 coupe

BMW M4 Competition Package review - does it fix the M4's faults?

The Competition Package is a significant improvement on the base model and it represents excellent value for money
11 Mar 2016
BMW M4 coupe

444bhp for BMW M3 and M4 Competition Package

Engine, performance and visual tweaks for the M3, M4 Coupe and M4 Convertible
14 Jan 2016
BMW M4 coupe

BMW Individual reveals Special 25th anniversary M4

Added luxury for special edition car
23 Jun 2015
BMW M4 coupe

BMW M4 vs BMW M5 - evo Deadly Rivals

Two German giants battle it out to find the true 'thrill of driving'
6 Mar 2015
BMW M4 coupe

Is this the best looking safety car ever? BMW's M4 MotoGP offering

Titanium exhaust, carbon spoiler and flashing lights. What more could you want?
13 Feb 2015
BMW M4 coupe

BMW M4 shows off laser headlights with CES concept

BMW's laser headlight technology, first seen in the i8, takes another step forward at CES
8 Jan 2015
BMW M4 coupe

BMW M4 tuned by AC Schnitzer

German tuner AC Schnitzer has released details of its 502bhp BMW M4 at the Essen motor show
28 Nov 2014
BMW M4 coupe

BMW M4 Champion Edition and 1-Series DTM Sport Edition

BMW has produced new M4 Champion Edition and 1-Series DTM Sport Edition packs to celebrate its DTM Championship wins
20 Oct 2014
BMW M4 coupe

BMW M4 v Porsche 911 Carrera track battle video

With the BMW M4's direct rivals getting on a bit, we pit it against a foe far tougher - the Porsche 911 Carrera. Track battle video here
30 Jul 2014