Find a car review


Audi RS5 review – finally an M4 beater?

Unfazed by all weathers, the RS5 offers huge performance and refinement, although it still wants for more character.

Evo rating
from £63,615
  • Effortless performance, confidence-inspiring handling, impressive refinement and comfort
  • Characterless engine, lack of driver involvement

The original Audi RS5 debuted in 2010 and was arguably the brand’s best attempt yet to recapture the magic of its legendary ur Quattro. Featuring a similar four-seat coupe body, flared wheel arches and four-wheel drive, it ticked all the right boxes. And while it lacked the original’s five-cylinder soundtrack, it compensated with its howling V8.

In fact, this naturally aspirated 4.2-litre 8-cylinder unit was the dynamic highlight. The rest of the car just failed to live up to the promise of its raw ingredients. It was fast and composed, but it lacked the driver involvement that marked out the best, such as the BMW M4.

> Audi RS5 vs BMW M4 vs Mercedes-AMG C63 S - Supertest review

Subscribe to evo magazine

If you're passionate about the world's greatest performance cars, experience the thrill of driving with evo magazine. Try your first 5 issues for £5.

However, there’s now an all-new Audi RS5 that’s been developed to address the old version’s shortcomings. Lighter, faster and powered by a powerful new twin turbocharged V6, it promises to be one of the firm’s most engaging and entertaining machines yet. At least that’s what Audi claims.

Before you even so much as open the driver’s door Audi is keen to point out that the RS5 has been designed to cover a wider brief than its immediate rivals. In fact, bosses stress that this is a high performance GT car that can be transformed into razor-sharp sports coupe as and when the mood takes.

Audi RS5 in detail 

> Performance and 0-60 time - The RS5 edges out the competition in a launch style start covering 0-62mph in 3.9sec and is capable of de-limited 174mph top speed.

Advertisement - Article continues below

> Engine and gearbox - The 2.9-litre, twin-turbocharged V6 develops 444bhp, but the gains have been made in the mid-range courtesy of 442lb ft of torque available from 1900rpm.

> Ride and handling - The new RS5 has progressed significantly over the old model, lighter, more focused and hugely capable, although it still feels a bit inert alongside rivals.

> MPG and running costs - The smaller blown engine makes the RS5 more efficient than its predecessor, with Audi claiming 32.5mpg on a combined cycle.

> Interior and tech - The RS5 does justice to Audi’s reputation of producing class-leading interiors crammed with an endless list of tech functions.

> Design - A collection of tasteful exterior tweaks imbue the RS5 with the necessary aggression to wear the RS badge.

Advertisement - Article continues below

> Audi RS5 vs rivals - evo 240 saw the Audi RS5 meet the M4 Competition Pack and Mercedes-AMG C63 in an evo Supertest.

Prices and specs

Priced at £63,615 in standard trim, the RS5 splits BMW’s M4 and Mercedes-AMG’s C63 in terms of price, however like these rivals, you can upgrade to a more expensive trim in the shape of the Carbon Edition (£76,115).

For the hefty premium Audi fits bigger wheels, matrix LED headlights and plenty of carbonfibre addenda, inside and out; the front/rear spoilers, sill extensions and diffuser insert are all made from the lightweight material. The package does lend the RS5 some welcome aggression – that said, it's not worth the £13k in our eyes. One aesthetic-based visual option we can recommend specifying, though, is the £645 Sonoma Green paint finish.

> BMW M4 review

Moreover, the performance-based options on offer are certainly worth looking at: dynamic ride control (£2000) and dynamic steering (£900) constitute the chassis upgrades available; the former is a must have, while the jury is still out on the latter, as it is on the £6000 carbon-ceramic brakes (unless you have track work in mind). While pricey, at £900, the head-up display is a useful addition that augments Audi’s virtual cockpit instrument display.

There’s no arguing the BMW M4 is a more precise driving tool than the RS5, even more so in Competition Pack specification (£64k), with a more involving chassis on account of its rear-driven set-up – it is an M car, after all. However, it can’t play the continent-crusher as well as the comfortable Audi.

Advertisement - Article continues below

> Mercedes-AMG C63 review

In AMG fashion the C63 is marked out by its powerplant. Where rivals opt for six-cylinder engines, the C63 – in true tradition – has a 469bhp V8, and it makes no secret of it, bellowing out a typically raucous AMG soundtrack, hauling you down the road with no let-up.


More on RS5

Audi RS5 hatchback

Audi RS5 Sportback review - how does it compare to the Mercedes-AMG C63 S?

The first Audi RS5 Sportback might lack the edge of Alfa’s Giulia Quadrifoglio, but its less frantic approach has strong appeal
15 Jul 2019
Audi RS5 hatchback

Used Audi RS5 8T (2010 - 2016) - buying guide - Used Audi RS5 8T (2010 - 2016) - checkpoints

Can a naturally aspirated, 444bhp sports coupe possibly be a bad second-hand buy?
3 Nov 2018
Audi RS5 hatchback

Used Audi RS5 8T (2010 - 2016) - buying guide

Can a naturally aspirated, 444bhp sports coupe possibly be a bad second-hand buy?
2 Nov 2018
Audi RS5 hatchback

Audi RS5 Sportback revealed – Audi’s impressive GT just got more practical

New Audi RS5 Sportback to bridge the practicality gap between the RS5 Coupe and RS4 Avant
31 Mar 2018
Audi RS5 hatchback

Abt RS5-R – German tuner takes Audi RS5 beyond 500bhp

Already-potent Audi RS5 gets power and suspension tweaks and races to 62mph in 3.6sec
25 Jan 2018
Audi RS5 hatchback

2017 Audi RS5 review - Audi's most entertaining coupe yet?

A more rounded car than before, delivering crushing all-weather pace, but comfort and refinement comes at the expense of character
26 Jun 2017
Audi RS5 hatchback

2017 Audi RS5 - UK price announced for powerful new coupe

The second generation Audi RS5 adopts Audi’s aggressive styling language for Sport models, and harbours a new 2.9-litre V6 engine
3 May 2017
Audi RS5 hatchback

Audi RS5 Cabriolet review, price and specs

The Audi RS5 gets a facelift and a new soft-top Cabriolet variant. How does it fare compared to Porsche 911, Jaguar F-type and BMW M3?
24 Mar 2014
Audi RS5 hatchback

Audi RS5 Cabrio unveiled

Audi has unveiled the RS5 Cabrio, a drop-top version of the 444bhp V8 quattro Coupe
7 Sep 2012
Audi RS5 hatchback

Audi and Ducati Pikes Peak video

Audi and Ducati's partnership debuts via a big budget video at Pikes Peak
13 Aug 2012
Audi RS5 hatchback

2012 Audi RS5 from £58,725

Audi has announced a slightly updated RS5 for 2012, now offered with an optional 'Sport' package
21 Feb 2012
Audi RS5 hatchback

New Audi RS5 coupe revealed

The two-door Audi RS5 quattro gets a refresh alongside its A5 and S5 brethren while Audi pulls the wraps off stunning A5 DTM racing car
14 Sep 2011
Audi RS5 hatchback

Audi RS5 quattro coupe review

It's got the latest quattro hardware and a high-revving 444bhp V8, all wrapped in a coupe bodyshell, but is the all-new RS5 a genuine M3 beater?
18 Apr 2010