Just looking – BMW M5 (E34)

Add £26k to an F10 M5 and you get the new Competition Edition. Half that gets the last inline-six M5...

This week BMW revealed the latest limited-edition version of its M5, dubbed the Competition Edition.

The latest M5 is a fantastic car and even more so with close to 600bhp, but there’s always a nagging doubt with modern M cars that they’re not quite as special as they used to be.

Take the E34 BMW M5, for instance. There was little wrong with a standard E34-generation BMW 5-series, but the M5 seemed so fundamentally different from a 525i or similar that you couldn’t help but covet one – it was as special in its own way as a supercar from the era. The modern M5 is blisteringly fast, but is it as desirable?

Given the latest Competition Edition costs a six-figure sum, probably not. Certainly not when you can get a pristine example of the E34 M5 for £12,495, like this example for sale with Autounion in Corby, via Classic and Performance Car.

Granted, with 340bhp at 6900rpm and 295lb ft of torque, modern M5 performance is out of the question. But 5.9sec to 60mph is hardly slow and both old and new M5s are constrained by the same 155mph limiter.

And in other areas, we reckon the new M5 is eclipsed by the E34. Its turbocharged V8 simply can’t match the aural appeal of the howling, individual throttle-bodied 3.8-litre inline six of the old car, for a start.

Then there’s the question of usable performance. A 592bhp saloon with massive reserves of grip requires a significant and almost dangerous commitment to speed to come alive on public roads, but an old E34 M5 is a model of all-speeds feedback. Going slower than the new car just means spending longer enjoying the process of driving.

‘As an advert for rear-drive,’ said John Barker way back in issue 10 of evo magazine, ‘the E34 M5 is up there with the very best. A saloon of this size really shouldn’t have this much composure and this level of responsiveness. Best of all, though, you never feel you’re hustling the car to do something it doesn’t want to: it’s enjoying the drive as much as you are.’

Notably, M5s of this generation were also manual-only, so there’s another check-mark in the E34’s “involvement” box.

This example has covered 112,000 miles and apparently boasts a full service history. It looks perfectly original too – right down to the desirable Daytona Violet paintwork and the divisive ‘turbine’ wheel covers.

And there’s something quite appealing in the idea of buying an entire E34 M5 for considerably less than the difference in price between a regular F10 M5 and the new Competition Edition.

> Find BMW M5s for sale on Classic and Performance Car

Recommended

BMW M5 Competition F90 review
BMW M5 Competition 2020 Front Quarter
BMW M5 saloon

BMW M5 Competition F90 review

The BMW M5 is now only available in Competition trim in the UK, but this is no bad thing as it remains a finer-honed version of the standard M5
18 Mar 2022
Early 2024 BMW M5 prototype confirms plug-in hybrid powertrain
BMW M5 2024 prototype – front quarter
BMW M5 saloon

Early 2024 BMW M5 prototype confirms plug-in hybrid powertrain

The next BMW M5 has been spotted testing for the first time, will it live up to the brilliant CS?
12 Jan 2022
BMW M5 CS 2022 review – our 2021 evo car of the year
BMW M5 CS – ecoty tracking
BMW M5 saloon

BMW M5 CS 2022 review – our 2021 evo car of the year

Nonsensical on paper, but sublime in practice. Never has a modern supersaloon been more tactile or more engaging
6 Jan 2022

Most Popular

Audi RS4 and RS5 Competition revealed – key chassis upgrades for Audi Sport’s BMW M3 rival
Audi RS4 Avant – front quarter
Audi RS4

Audi RS4 and RS5 Competition revealed – key chassis upgrades for Audi Sport’s BMW M3 rival

RS4 Avant and RS5 Coupe and Sportback soon to be available with limited-build Competition packs
17 May 2022
McLaren 600LT v Porsche 911 GT3 v Nissan GT-R Nismo
McLaren 600LT v Porsche 911 GT3 v Nissan GT-R Nismo
Supercars

McLaren 600LT v Porsche 911 GT3 v Nissan GT-R Nismo

What will it take to expose any weaknesses in the new 911 GT3? Nissan’s brutal GT-R Nismo and McLaren’s ballistic 600LT should have the power and poli…
14 May 2022
Used car deals of the week
header
used cars

Used car deals of the week

This week, we found a special McLaren 12C, a rare Mazda RX-7 and more
19 May 2022