Ask Goodwin – Should we spy on our kids behind the wheel?

Goodwin gives us his opinion of fitting insurance black boxes to youngsters' cars

Would you put a black box in your child’s car? I’m considering it. Paul Gunn, Hemel Hemptsead.

It’s an interesting one. My daughter (my only offspring) learnt to drive about six years ago, which was about the time the idea of putting telemetry into cars to monitor driver behaviour was first mooted. And, I think, first available. It was irrelevant for us because there was no way that I was going to buy her a new car, a) Because I had to buy my own car when I was a teenager and b) All my spare cash goes into my own fleet of vehicles. So she bought herself a tatty, but sound Peugeot 206. I think the insurance was about £700 a year that she paid monthly. This car was replaced by another 206 and more recently by an Mk1 Mazda MX-5 which cost her under £500 for TPF&T cover. 

Subscribe to evo magazine

evo is 21 and to celebrate, we're returning to 1998 prices! Subscribe now to SAVE 39% on the shop price and get evo for its original cover price of £3.00 an issue, plus get a FREE gift worth £25!

Had I had a windfall and been a more generous father it might have been a different story and she would have had a brand new car. The trouble is, a black box is very much against my principles. I’m a bit old fashioned and I think kids should learn to be responsible for their own actions. Get caught speeding, have a crash or commit another point accumulating offence and your insurance premium will go up. Be sensible and all would be good.

I have a similar attitude to risk taking. I wasn’t too worried about her buying the Mazda even though being a Mk1 (hers was that basic steel-wheeled model with the 1.6 engine) it was missing active safety kit such as ABS and didn’t have an airbag to its name. I explained to her that it would be more challenging to drive than her 206s and that she should be cautious in the wet and leave generous gaps and long braking distances. 

Advertisement - Article continues below

But to answer the original question, I think I would put the question to the offspring involved. If they’d be happy with a spy in the cab and the possible savings in car insurance (if they were paying for it themselves) then they should have one fitted.

Ask Goodwin is a new weekly column on evo.co.uk by Colin Goodwin, one of the UK's most popular motoring journalists – and one of the early contributors to evo magazine. 

You'd like Colin – he drove an amphibious vehicle across the English channel (it caught fire half way) and he held the Guinness World Record for the highest speed in reverse (104 mph in a Light Car Company Rocket). More recently he drove from England to the Geneva motor show… in a Caterham 160.

Oh, and when he visits the evo office he does so in a plane that he built in his shed…

Check back every Wednesday lunchtime for a new column, and get involved with #askgoodwin either at @askgoodwin (Colin's Twitter) or @evomagazine

Make sure to get involved in the Ask Goodwin debate on our Facebook page here. You can also put your vote in via the poll system found on the evo.co.uk homepage.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Most Popular

Volkswagen Golf GTI hatchback

New Volkswagen Golf GTI leaked ahead of reveal

Following a slew of spy shots last year, a camo-free Mk8 Golf GTI surfaces online
20 Jan 2020
Ford Focus RS

Ford Focus RS500 v Audi RS3 – new v used

One’s an eight-year-old Ford, the other a brand new Audi. But which of these five‑cylinder superhatches deserves your £45k?
18 Jan 2020

Lotus's badge-engineered specials: from Cortina to Carlton and VX220

Some collaborations more secretive than others, a handful of models have received backing from Lotus over the years. We've gathered the very best
19 Jan 2020
Hyundai i30 N

Hyundai i30 Fastback N versus the Nurburgring

We brought the Hyundai i30 Fastback back to its spiritual home in Germany's Eifel mountains, where there is a racing track you might well have heard o…
7 Oct 2019