Mercedes-Benz A200

Much improved A-class is still no hot hatch

Evo rating
Price
from £18,120
  • Original's chassis woes now sorted
  • Not a car you really want to punt hard

Elk, moose, deer, even the humble Fresian cow shouldn't hold any worries for the second incarnation of Mercedes' Tardis. Where the old A-class infamously went sump-over-grab-handle trying to evade cones representing wandering Scandinavian ruminants, the new one merely wafts around them, which translates to a much more enjoyable car, for us as well as them.

We tried the most powerful diesel and petrol versions currently available (there's a 200bhp turbocharged 2-litre petrol due at the end of the year) and it's nice to be able to sing the praises of the latter rather than the former. The petrol comes with only five gears to the derv's six, and 136bhp versus 140bhp, but it feels much the more flexible and gutsy unit, punting along at a brisk yet refined pace with decent urge when you want it at motorway speeds.

Subscribe to evo magazine

Subscribe today to have every issue of evo delivered straight to you. You'll SAVE 39% on the shop price, and get evo for its original cover price for a whole year!

Although the driving position is high, you don't get the waving sensation of being at the top of a tree in a gale through the corners. The driving position is also less van-like, and the rest of the interior is as spacious as Mercedes claims, although whether it's what you'd expect for the £26K of our specced-up test car is debatable. The £500 optional Harman Kardon stereo was, however, fantastic. As far as the outside goes, you can make up your own mind, but it does seem odd that when form so obviously follows function, anyone would bother to specify the convenience-robbing three-door.

In everyday driving the A-class is refreshingly accomplished, with a good ride/handling trade-off. It's best through bigger corners on more open A- and B-roads where you can use the laterally stable chassis to best effect. The wide-feeling front track doesn't really key into the tarmac through tighter, more nadgety turns and the outside front wheel always seems to be trying to bear too much of the cornering duties. A touch of trail-braking does help, but few owners will drive it like that.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

In truth, you wouldn't really expect an A-class to be some B-road hero anyway. Much better to enjoy sweeping along bigger roads, cheerfully waving at all the animals as you go.

Specifications

EngineIn-line 4cyl, 2035cc
Max power136bhp @ 5750rpm
Max torque136lb ft @ 3500-4000rpm
0-609.8sec (claimed)
Top speed125mph (claimed)
On saleNow
Advertisement

Recommended

Visit/mercedes/a-class/202208/mercedes-amg-a35-saloon-2020-review
Mercedes A-Class

Mercedes-AMG A35 Saloon 2020 review

7 Feb 2020
Visit/mercedes/a-class/22021/mercedes-amg-a35-2020-review-amgs-shot-at-the-vw-golf-r
Mercedes A-Class hatchback

Mercedes-AMG A35 2020 review – AMG’s shot at the VW Golf R

24 Jan 2020
Advertisement

Most Popular

Visit/news/22743/gordon-murray-automotive-t50-revealed-the-real-mclaren-f1-successor
News

Gordon Murray Automotive T.50 revealed – the real McLaren F1 successor

Gordon Murray’s T.50 is the pinnacle of supercar engineering on the eve of an electrified future
4 Aug 2020
Visit/features/202947/bmw-m3-gts-vs-mini-gp-vs-renault-sport-megane-r26r
Features

BMW M3 GTS vs Mini GP vs Renault Sport Mégane R26.R

You could spend £250,000 on a 700bhp hardcore machine, but is there just as much fun to be had – if not more – with less power and for less outlay?
1 Aug 2020
Visit/ford/202957/mountune-ford-focus-rs-m520-2020-review-less-hot-hatch-more-throwback-to-group-b
Ford Focus RS

Mountune Ford Focus RS M520 2020 review – less hot hatch, more Group B throwback

The idea of a 500-horse Focus won’t be for everyone, but for the rest it’s a glorious dose of internal combustion madness
31 Jul 2020
Visit/bmw/m2/202954/bmw-m2-cs-2020-review-plenty-to-worry-a-porsche-cayman-gt4
BMW M2

BMW M2 CS 2020 review – there's plenty to worry a Porsche Cayman GT4

The most enjoyable and rewarding M car to drive for quite some time. Potentially, a future classic.
31 Jul 2020