Porsche Panamera S 4.8 manual review

We drive the Panamera S with the very rare manual gearbox. Is it better than the PDK?

Evo rating
  • Nice to drive and sounds great
  • As visually challenged as the rest of the range

What is it?

The Porsche Panamera S - as before, but sampled with the manual gearbox that we’ve not driven until now. Even having the option of a stick makes the Panamera an extreme rarity in this segment, but for determined self-shifters the S’s combination of 395bhp and a six-speed gearbox offers strong appeal. It’s £2000 cheaper than the PDK-equipped automatic, too. It costs £78,221, before the inevitable options workout.

Technical highlights

The arrival of the basic V6 Panamera has pushed the V8-fitted S to the middle of the model tree, between the entry-level car and the mighty Turbo. As before, it uses a 4.8-litre direct injection V8 developed from the engine  found in the Cayenne. The manual transmission is claimed to add 0.2 seconds to the claimed 0-62mph time compared to the PDK, although the official economy figures are considerably further apart - on the official European test the manual box scores 22.6mpg compared to the PDK’s 26.2mpg.

What’s it like to drive?

There’s something immensely satisfying about the tactile experience of a big car, a big engine and a manual gearbox. The Panamera S isn’t mega fast by segment standards - although Porsche claims a 177mph top speed if you can find a long enough straight. The V8 engine is happy to grumble along at low revs - something the shift-happy PDK rarely allows when left in its auto mode - although it needs to be revved hard to deliver its best.

Fortunately, the manual box’s gearshift action possesses exactly the sort of weight and heft you’d hope to find in a manual Porsche. Even better, the solid brake pedal acts as a steady enough fulcrum for that endangered driving pleasure: the heel-and-toe gearchange. And don’t be too scared of that fuel economy figure, either - on our experience it’s probably far closer to the mpg delivered by the PDK than the official figures suggest. 

How does it compare?

You’ll struggle to find another manual gearbox in a saloon offering similar performance - especially with BMW confirming European versions of the new M5 will only come with flappy paddles. The VXR8 is the only rival that springs to mind - albeit for not much more than half the price.

Anything else I need to know?

You’ll be in a small minority, with even Porsche admitting that the manual Panamera is always going to be an extremely small seller. And for that reason, be aware the third pedal is likely to come with a sizeable extra residual hit come resale time. 

Specifications

EngineV8, 4806cc
Max power395bhp @ 6000rpm
Max torque369lb ft @ 3500-5000rpm
0-605.6sec (claimed 0-62mph)
Top speed177mph

Most Popular

Porsche Taycan Cross Turismo revealed – 750bhp Turbo S to top crossover range
Porsche Taycan Cross Turismo - Turbo S front static
Porsche Taycan

Porsche Taycan Cross Turismo revealed – 750bhp Turbo S to top crossover range

Porsche expands Taycan range with new Cross Turismo high-riding estate
4 Mar 2021
BMW M3 and M4 lifted to 612bhp by Manhart Performance 
Manhart Performance BMW M3
BMW M3 saloon

BMW M3 and M4 lifted to 612bhp by Manhart Performance 

German tuner Manhart Performance has extracted more performance from BMW’s new M3 and M4
4 Mar 2021
Next Ferrari hypercar spied in development
2021 Ferrari hybrid hypercar prototype - front quarter
Ferrari

Next Ferrari hypercar spied in development

Ferrari’s next ground-breaking hypercar is on its way
3 Mar 2021