Skip advert
Advertisement
Long term tests

Jaguar S-type 4.2 V8 R

A memory comes back to me from the early '90s, of driving the then-new 3.8-litre version of the M5. I can vividly remember being blown away by the Beemer and, being a bit of a Jaguar fan, thinking: 'Wouldn't it be great if Jaguar made proper sports saloons again, a bit like the 3.8-litre Mk2 of the early 60s.' Well, today it does. It even looks like a Mk2.

A memory comes back to me from the early '90s, of driving the then-new 3.8-litre version of the M5. I can vividly remember being blown away by the Beemer and, being a bit of a Jaguar fan, thinking: 'Wouldn't it be great if Jaguar made proper sports saloons again, a bit like the 3.8-litre Mk2 of the early 60s.' Well, today it does. It even looks like a Mk2.

And in many ways the S-type R is everything a sporting Jaguar saloon should be. Lots of smooth, easy power; effortless ground-covering; a supple ride and a snugly sumptuous interior with just the right degree of raciness. After all those years of elegant but rather toothless XJ saloons, I'm chuffed that there's a proper compact sports saloon with a Jaguar badge that we're proud to have on the fleet.

So how has it been, living with the S-type day-to-day? Terrific, actually, but with a couple of provisos. As road test ed Bovingdon commented the other day, it's a shame they don't fit a limited slip diff. Knock out the traction control, flatten the throttle in a low-speed turn or away from a junction and chances are you'll be treated to lots of wheelspin and not much else. Now, not everyone drives everywhere like young Mr B, but we all like to let our hair down from time to time. It would be nice to have the option.

The other flaw in the R's dynamic make-up is the response to the brake pedal. No doubting the power of the impressive-looking callipers and ventilated discs, but I don't want to be reminded of it every time I so much as touch the pedal. Such is the servo assistance that it's near impossible to feather the brakes, to bleed away a little speed, and if you like to drive smoothly, to measure out your inputs with a degree of sensitivity, it's a major irritation. Power, as someone once said, is nothing without control.

Running Costs

Date acquiredDecember 2004
Total mileage9356
Costs this month£0
Mileage this month3131
MPG this month21.8
Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

New 2027 BMW M3 electric prototype review – the EV we've all been waiting for
BMW M3 Electric
Reviews

New 2027 BMW M3 electric prototype review – the EV we've all been waiting for

BMW M is more excited about the new electric M3 than it is about the next-generation combustion model. Now we are too...
16 Nov 2026
Mazda MX-5 (NC, 2005-2015) review – a rear-wheel drive roadster bargain
Mazda MX-5 NC
In-depth reviews

Mazda MX-5 (NC, 2005-2015) review – a rear-wheel drive roadster bargain

It took us a while to warm to Mazda’s third-generation MX-5, but for enthusiasts on a budget it might be the best option of them all
17 Nov 2026
Lucid Air Sapphire review – one of the best EVs we've driven
Lucid Air Sapphire
Reviews

Lucid Air Sapphire review – one of the best EVs we've driven

With three electric motors, an overhauled chassis and calibration and tuning inspired by the BMW M5 CS, the Lucid Air Sapphire gives us hope that big …
16 Nov 2026