Long term tests

Jaguar S-Type 4.2 V8 R

The Jag has now been back with us for more than a month since the prolonged investigation into its electronic epilepsy. It has also become clear why it was the best part of two months before Jaguar was happy to return it. But first a quick recap: the R's central locking was the first thing to go on the blink; later, while on the move, the car started to suffer from a sudden jolting sensation at the rear axle, as if the power was being cut abruptly; then it began refusing to start; and finally, after one par

The Jag has now been back with us for more than a month since the prolonged investigation into its electronic epilepsy. It has also become clear why it was the best part of two months before Jaguar was happy to return it. But first a quick recap: the R's central locking was the first thing to go on the blink; later, while on the move, the car started to suffer from a sudden jolting sensation at the rear axle, as if the power was being cut abruptly; then it began refusing to start; and finally, after one particular fit, it locked the transmission in Park.

Sent to Coventry on the back of a recovery truck, the S-type became the subject of a detailed investigation by Jaguar engineers, who eventually traced the problem to a single damaged wire in the front-end wiring harness. The critical thing was, this wire was an electrical feed to two units that govern a range of vehicle functions, hence the various maladies.

Worryingly, the damage was found to have been caused by chafing under a front wheelarch, at which stage the chief programme engineer was called in. Enquiries within the dealer network revealed that 'a handful' of other S-types had suffered the same problem.

The engineers effected a modification, described by a Jaguar spokesman as 'one hundred per cent robust for the life of the vehicle', which will now be carried out on other S-types when they visit a dealership for routine servicing. Our S-type R was then subjected to a 500-mile road test before it was returned to us. And it seems to be absolutely fine.

So there you are. A fairly freakish fault, thoroughly investigated and resolved by Jaguar. Can't really fault them for that. But naturally it's dented our faith in the S-type. Confidence is slowly seeping back, but I'm not sure I'll ever think of it in quite the same way again.

Which is a pity, because it's a very long way from being a bad car. It's quick and refined and comfortable. It had also, up until it threw its wobbler, been 100 per cent reliable and painless to live with. As with all forced-induction engines, if you use the Jag's full performance the fuel consumption plummets to the mid-teens, but generally it returns low-20s. Oil consumption has been negligible. The original ContiSportContact tyres lasted for well over 20,000 miles - a replacement set went on last month at a pretty reasonable £630 from our friendly local tyre-fitter, Central Tyres of Wellingborough.

Good car, the R. Just a shame about that chafing...

Running Costs

Date acquiredDecember 2004
Total mileage25,182
Costs this month£630 (tyres)
Mileage this month1627
MPG this month21.6mpg

Most Popular

Visit/mclaren/203105/five-mclaren-senna-gtr-lms-in-le-mans-liveries-revealed
McLaren Senna

Five McLaren Senna GTR LMs in Le Mans liveries revealed

Celebrating 25 years since McLaren’s domination of the 1995 Le Mans 24hr with the F1 GTR
18 Sep 2020
Visit/bmw/1-series/203095/bmw-128ti-revealed-as-direct-hot-hatch-rival-to-vw-golf-gti
BMW 1 Series

BMW 128ti revealed as direct hot hatch rival to VW Golf GTI

BMW has revealed a simplified front-wheel drive hot 1-series called 128ti that will sit below the M135i performance flagship
16 Sep 2020
Visit/nissan/370z/201879/nissan-z-proto-revealed-v6-twin-turbo-six-speed-manual-and-a-catch
Nissan 370Z

Nissan Z Proto revealed – V6 twin-turbo, six-speed manual, and a catch

It’s the Nissan sports car we’ve been waiting 11 years for, but don’t hold your breath for it in the UK
16 Sep 2020
Visit/best-cars/203098/the-worlds-10-best-gt-cars-6-4
Best cars

The world's 10 best GT cars - 6-4

These cars have the ability to make long-distance journeys relaxing while still being able to thrill on a twisting road
16 Sep 2020