Mini Roadster Cooper S review

The Mini Roadster is yet another spin-off, sharing much of the Mini Coupe's styling with the Mini Cabriolet's collapsable roof. But can it deliver on substance as well as style?

Evo rating
Price
from £20,900
  • Distinctive looks, great engine in JCW
  • Poor refinement, scuttle shake, lack of driving focus

What is it?

Yet another slightly different Mini variant – or, if you’re of a more cynical disposition, the bottom of a well-scraped barrel. The Mini Roadster is a soft-top version of the two-seat Coupe, sharing its sister’s lower windscreen line but with what we’re promised is a greater emphasis on driving dynamics than the existing, four-seat Mini Cabriolet. 

The Roadster will be sold with the same selection of petrol and diesel engines as the Coupe. But, despite losing two seats and a fair percentage of its windscreen, the Roadster is £500 more expensive than the equivalent cabrio.

Technical highlights?

We’re struggling on this one. The Roadster gets a reworked version of the Cabriolet’s bodyshell, with reinforcement to compensate for the lost roof. Chassis settings are very close to those of the Coupe. The Cooper S that we drove is powered by a 181bhp 1.6-litre turbocharged engine, with drive supplied to the front wheels by a six-speed manual gearbox.

The folding roof mechanism is a basic system that reflects the Roadster’s pared-back ethos. Instead of the Cabriolet’s sliding and folding mechanism the Mini Roadster has a simple ‘throw back’ fabric roof that requires users to unlatch the roof and then physically heave it backwards (we’re told that power operation will be standard in the UK.) 

What’s it like to drive?

A disappointment, if we’re honest. Dynamically the Roadster sticks closely to the established Mini script with keen reactions and plenty of entertainment to be had from ringing out the torquey turbocharged engine.

But, like the Cabriolet, it suffers from noticeable shuttle shake, which really takes the edge off the driving experience. On our Portuguese test route, and with a car wearing the ‘standard’ 16-inch alloys, it wasn’t too bad. But on Britain’s rougher roads and riding on the larger optional alloys that many buyers are likely to pick, we fear it’s going to become a big issue.

It’s hard not to conclude that form came before function in the Roadster. The roof does without a proper interior lining meaning that you have to look at its internal frame when it’s in place. And roof-up refinement is poor, with lots of wind and road noise getting into the cabin at everyday speeds. 

Fashionistas will love the Roadster’s quirky speedster looks, but we’re struggling to see what it adds to what’s already offered by the cheaper and more refined Mini Cabriolet. And if you’re looking for a two seat Mini to actually drive, then the Coupe is definitely the better bet. 

How does it compare?

That depends on what you regard the Roadster as being a rival to. It will certainly win you more attention than something like an Audi TT Roadster, and at a substantial saving. But if you want to get some driving pleasure with your fresh air then the Mazda MX-5 is cheaper and far more dynamically accomplished. 

Anything else I should know?

This is almost the last iteration of the current generation ‘R56’ Mini – we’ll see the new, third-generation hatchback in 2013.

Specifications

Engine1598cc four cylinder, turbocharged, petrol
Max power181bhp @ 5500rpm
Max torque177lb ft @ 1600rpm
0-607-sec
Top speed140mph
On saleMarch 2012

Most Popular

2022 BMW M3 Touring teased ahead of reveal
2022 BMW M3 Touring
BMW M3

2022 BMW M3 Touring teased ahead of reveal

BMW has released new images of its upcoming M3 Touring before it reaches customers next year
24 Sep 2021
Porsche 911 Carrera 4 GTS 2022 review – middle child 992 shapes up
Porsche 911 GTS review (992) – front cornering
Porsche 911 Carrera

Porsche 911 Carrera 4 GTS 2022 review – middle child 992 shapes up

Two and a half years after the launch of the 992, the GTS treatment both adds and subtracts but does the result gel on the road?
21 Sep 2021
Lotus Emira First Edition priced from £75,995 – production to commence in 2022
Lotus Emira
Lotus

Lotus Emira First Edition priced from £75,995 – production to commence in 2022

First examples of the new Lotus Emira will roll off the production line early next year, with the entry-level four-cylinder to follow
20 Sep 2021