An Aston Martin scolding – evo Archive

When evo was summoned to Gaydon for daring to dislike the DB9

evo archive 295

‘The launch was in Tourrettes,’ recalls Dickie.

‘F***ing hell,’ says John.

Before anyone pedantic spoils the beautifully foul-mouthed moment and starts talking about the extra ‘r’, conversation returns to the Aston Martin DB9, which was the car that was launched in the south of France. I’m quizzing John Barker, Dickie Meaden and Jethro Bovingdon about the beautiful GT because the whole saga around the 9 has always fascinated me. 

A couple of months before I joined evo in 2004, the cover of issue 070 had a group test on it; the new Aston posed front and centre, with backing vocals being provided by a Porsche 911 Turbo, a Bentley Continental GT and a Mercedes SL55 AMG. But it was the words underneath the photo that packed the punch: ‘DB9: WHY IT FAILS ITS TOUGHEST TEST’. It was intriguing and rather fearless and as a reader I liked it.

> Aston Martin V12 Vantage 2022 review – why it fails as a fitting sign-off for the Aston V12

In an age of clickbait, it probably doesn’t seem that brave or bold. But it takes a lot more guts to print something on the cover of a magazine that will be on shop shelves for a month than it does to publish something online that can be changed in the CMS in a few seconds. Certainly Peter Tomalin’s Ed Speak suggested it wasn’t a decision that was taken lightly. ‘There has been much furrowing of brows and chewing of biros in the office these past few days…’ he began, before going on to acknowledge that, not for the first time, evo’s opinion was out of step with those of other motoring mags. 

In the past the magazine hadn’t been crossed off any Christmas card lists for its criticisms, but Peter noted that not everyone took fault-finding well: ‘Criticise Ferrari and you’re virtually excommunicated. The Italians take it extremely personally. And the Brits (and Germans) who run Aston’s splendid new factory at Gaydon? I’ll let you know next month.’

Well, it’s fair to say that some at Aston didn’t take it very well. John and Jethro were summoned to Gaydon…

‘It was a very weird thing because they called us in basically to tell us off and to tell us why we were wrong,’ says a still slightly bemused Bovingdon

The crux of evo’s issue with the car was that the ride quality of the DB9 was far from resolved and the steering response was amiss too. Something seemed to have gone awry between the car Dickie drove on the launch in France (seemingly with much better, pre-production dampers) and those that reached the media for tests in the UK. This was the second sub-par DB9 that the magazine had experienced too, so it wasn’t down to one rogue example. 

Aston Martin DB9

‘I remember that one of us pointed out to Aston that the Vanquish was so much more comfortable, so much more composed,’ continues Jethro, ‘yet the Vanquish was the supercar and the DB9 was supposed to be the GT.’

‘I said, “What would you choose to drive to the south of France in?”’ remembers John, ‘and this pompous marketing man blustered, “Oh, DB9 every time,” and I knew we were wasting our time.’

‘It was like someone trying to indoctrinate you or brainwash you. Shine lights in your eyes until you agree with them,’ says Jethro.

‘I remember that he didn’t join us for lunch in the canteen,’ concludes John, ‘but someone from PR did and as we were walking down there she said: “I agree with you. I prefer the Vanquish.”’

Most Popular

Toyota GR Yaris Gen 2 2024 review – first drive of the production ready hot hatch
Toyota GR Yaris – front

Toyota GR Yaris Gen 2 2024 review – first drive of the production ready hot hatch

We've driven a prototype GR Yaris Gen 2 on track, now we've driven a production car on ice. Is it still looking good for the ultimate supermini?
27 Feb 2024
New Alpine A290: latest details on the Renault 5's hot hatch cousin
Alpine A290 concept

New Alpine A290: latest details on the Renault 5's hot hatch cousin

Good news for fans of accessible performance, as Alpine reveals more details about its forthcoming EV hot hatch, the A290
26 Feb 2024
Hyundai i30 N and i20 N axed
Hyundai i30 N and i20 N

Hyundai i30 N and i20 N axed

Production of petrol-powered Hyundai N hot hatches has come to an end in Europe, with electric N models picking up the baton
23 Feb 2024