BMW i8 vs Porsche 911 - evo Deadly Rivals

An icon squares up to the new order, but which one will win?

For a long time Porsche hasn't had much to worry about in its segment of the sports car market. The 911 remains one of the most iconic cars ever made and continues to excite and thrill drivers with every iteration.

But then the BMW i8 came along and tried to do things differently. A hybrid powertrain was combined with cutting edge design, to deliver a truly modern mid-engined sports car. Crucially though, BMW promised it would be fun to drive too.

As such, for the next in our Deadly Rivals series, we thought it only fair we compare the two. We've got a Porsche 911 Carrera 4 GTS up against a BMW i8. Both four wheel drive, both around £100,000 and both hugely exciting in very different ways.

Specifications

BMW i8

Engine1,499cc 3cyl turbo + hybrid synchronous motor
Power357bhp
Torque420lb ft
0-62mph4.4 sec
Top Speed188 mph
MPG134.5
Lap time1:06.43

Porsche 911 Carrera 4 GTS

Engine3,800cc, flat-six
Power424bhp
Torque325lb ft
0-62mph4.0 sec (with PDK)
Top Speed188 mph
MPG31
Lap time1:02.66

Winner

Somewhat predictably, the 911 takes the win here. But don't let that put you off the i8, which proved to be a far more exciting ownership proposition after we'd given it some time on the track.

Read: BMW M5 vs BMW M4

The seed has been sown for the future and while the 911 continues to work its magic, an M-division i8 could mean a major threat to the Porsche crown.

Recommended

BMW i8 - review, history, prices and specs
BMW i8

BMW i8 - review, history, prices and specs

A genuinely ground-breaking car, the BMW i8 showed plug-in cars and driving pleasure didn’t need to be strangers
26 Nov 2020

Most Popular

2022 Nissan GT-R model year update revealed
MY22 Nissan GT-R T-spec – front quarter
Nissan GT-R

2022 Nissan GT-R model year update revealed

Two new special editions and the return of some iconic colours are the highlights of the Nissan GT-R’s MY22 update
14 Sep 2021
A dead Ferrari F40 in Switzerland – evo Archive
Ferrari F40
Ferrari F40

A dead Ferrari F40 in Switzerland – evo Archive

The story of a Ferrari F40, a flat battery, Swiss chocolate and sex toys…
7 Sep 2021
Tesla Model S Plaid breaks EV Nürburgring record – beats Porsche Taycan Turbo
Tesla Model S Plaid
Tesla Model S

Tesla Model S Plaid breaks EV Nürburgring record – beats Porsche Taycan Turbo

Tesla has now recorded a Nürburgring lap time with its Model S Plaid, if that matters
10 Sep 2021