Features

Jaguar XFR-S v Vauxhall VXR8 GTS

Bold colours and big V8s, but which is the one to go for?

With their pram handle rear wings, vibrant paintwork and ripping supercharged engines the XFR-S and VXR8 are most definitely the wild children of the current super saloon crop. They’re also among the most characterful and for those buyers who want to distinguish themselves from the multitude of German car drivers they are the only current alternatives.

Engine and Gearbox

Neither the XFR-S nor the VXR8 particularly concerns themselves with downsizing or fuel efficiency. It isn’t often that a supercharged Jaguar is outpunched, but on this occasion the big Vauxhall puts its output figures to shame.

Subscribe to evo magazine

evo is 21 and to celebrate, we're returning to 1998 prices! Subscribe now to SAVE 39% on the shop price and get evo for its original cover price of £3.00 an issue, plus get a FREE gift worth £25!

Using a 6.2-litre LS1 V8 with an Eaton supercharger, the VXR8 is good for 576bhp and 546lb ft of torque from 3850rpm. The Jaguar, meanwhile, is powered by a supercharged 5-litre V8 that develops 542bhp and 502lb ft from lower down in the rev range – 2500rpm. Both engines are mighty powerhouses that are full of charm.

The Jaguar uses an eight-speed automatic gearbox, which suits the car well and shifts cleanly in both manual and auto modes, while the Vauxhall uses a six-speed manual. That makes it a unique proposition in this sector and it also draws you into the process of driving in a way that no other super saloon does. The shift action is heavy and the throw is long, but it’s perfectly suited to the car as a whole.

Performance and 0-60mph

With so much power and torque on offer both the XFR-S and VXR8 are thumpingly quick. In contrast to the modern twin-turbocharged engines that are prevalent in this sector of the market today, they deliver their torque in a very linear way with immediate throttle response. That might cost them the brutal shove in the back of an Audi RS7 or BMW M5, but the trade off is that they feel more natural and exploitable when you’re really pressing on.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

The Jaguar is marginally quicker off the line – it hits 62mph in 4.6 seconds, compared to 4.9 seconds for the Vauxhall. Those figures only tell half the story, though, because both cars – rear-wheel drive only – are so traction limited from standing starts that they record unrepresentative acceleration times. Through the gears these cars will hold off a Porsche 911 Carrera S.  

The VXR8 is limited to 155mph, which means the 186mph XFR-S boasts a significant advantage at the top end. 

Ride and Handling

Both the XFR-S and VXR8 feel a little more relaxed in the way they ride over a bumpy road than the M5 for E63 – and that translates into a very different kind of driving experience.

In short, there’s more body movement in each car than you’d find in any of the German rivals. Rather than feeling completely locked down over crests and in corners, both the Jaguar and the Vauxhall roll and lean as the forces build. There the similarities end, though, because while the XFR-S’s body movement can make it feel wayward and on the edge of control, the VXR8’s movement instead feels natural and gives you an idea of where the grip is.

The Jaguar also has very light steering. In combination with the body movement that makes the first few miles feel like something of a wild ride – straight line performance is enormous, but the chassis feels loosely controlled. Keep the faith, though, and once you’ve become accustomed to the rate of response in the steering and the amount of vertical movement and roll you soon realise that the car will stick. It isn’t the most intuitive of super saloons at first acquaintance, but in time you learn that it can be flung around with most of the abandon of an M5. 

Advertisement - Article continues below

The VXR8 also feels very different to the German competition, but it takes less time to adjust than the XFR-S. It finds enormous grip, the front axle holds a line well and body control is strong, despite the slightly softer setup. The rear tyres also do a decent job of harnessing that monumental power and torque, too, so the big Vauxhall isn’t the handful you might expect it to be.

Price and Value

For the sheer performance it offers, the VXR8 is a total bargain at £54,499. It undercuts the XFR-S by some £25,000 without falling short in terms of performance or the driving experience.

Of course, where the Vauxhall is shown up is cabin quality and badge appeal. There is a small but committed audience for these cars, but the fact is that most German saloon car buyers would be put off by the loud styling and the comparatively cheap interior. That’s their loss, frankly, because the VXR8 is fun and characterful. 

The Jaguar also undercuts its German rivals by a useful amount, although it is starting to feel its age, particularly within the cabin. However, if you can live with that chunky rear wing, it is certainly among the better looking of super saloons and it offers all the performance you could hope for.

Verdict

For those buyers who aren’t put off by the badge or the image, the VXR8 is an easy car to recommend – particularly at that bargain price. The Jaguar remains an appealing car itself, though, and it’s a very worthwhile alternative to the established competition.

To find out how the XFR-S and VXR8 stack up against the best of the super saloon competition, check out May issue of Evo magazine (208).

 Specifications

EngineV8, 5000cc, supercharged
Power542bhp @ 6000-6500rpm
Torque501lb ft @ 2500-5500rpm
0-62mph4.4 sec (claimed)
Top Speed186mph (claimed)
MPG24.4mpg
Enginev8, 6162cc, supercharged
Power576bhp @ 6150rpm
Torque545lb ft @ 3850rpm
0-62mph4.2secs (claimed)
Top Speed155mph (claimed)
MPG18.5mpg
Advertisement

Recommended

Visit/subaru/202102/2020-subaru-levorg-sti-prototype-revealed-at-tokyo-auto-salon
Subaru Levorg

2020 Subaru Levorg STI prototype revealed at Tokyo Auto Salon

13 Jan 2020
Visit/jaguar/xe/202100/jaguar-xe-d180-hse-r-dynamic-awd-review-the-drivers-choice
Jaguar XE

Jaguar XE D180 HSE R-Dynamic AWD review - the driver's choice

10 Jan 2020
Visit/audi/202047/audi-rs-25th-anniversary-package-pays-homage-to-the-rs2-avant
Audi

Audi RS 25th Anniversary package pays homage to the RS2 Avant 

13 Dec 2019
Visit/porsche/porsche-panamera-sport-turismo/202021/2020-porsche-panamera-sport-turismo-spotted-testing
Porsche Panamera Sport Turismo

2020 Porsche Panamera Sport Turismo spotted testing 

6 Dec 2019
Advertisement

Most Popular

Visit/sports-cars/202115/porsche-ditches-four-cylinder-for-flat-six-in-cayman-and-boxster-gts
sports cars

Porsche ditches four-cylinder for flat-six in Cayman and Boxster GTS

New models eschew turbos with detuned 4-litre from the Spyder and GT4
15 Jan 2020
Visit/aston-martin/dbx-suv/15413/aston-martin-dbx-prototype-review-the-best-suv-yet
Aston Martin DBX SUV

Aston Martin DBX prototype review

It might be late to the party, but has Aston Martin’s first ever SUV nailed the brief?
15 Jan 2020
Visit/used-cars/19675/used-car-deals-of-the-week
used cars

Best used cars for sale this week

We’ve delved into the classifieds and chosen our favourite cars for sale this week
15 Jan 2020
Visit/hyundai/i30-n-hatchback/201775/hyundai-i30-n-versus-hyundai-i30-tcr
Hyundai i30 N hatchback

Hyundai i30 N versus Hyundai i30 TCR

Can Dickie Meaden beat Steve Sutcliffe in a straight(ish) race? We sent them to the Circuit Nuvolari with a pair of Hyundai i30 Ns to find out.
20 Sep 2019