Jaguar XF review - is the Jaguar's exec-saloon best in class?

An engaging drive, but rivals beat Jaguar in some areas

Evo rating
Price
from £33,835
  • Engaging chassis, ride comfort and handling
  • Restrictive engine choice, lacks cutting edge technology

Jaguar’s XF may be new in terms of interior and exterior looks, the materials used to make it and elements of the powertrains offered, but peel away its new aluminium intensive construction and the XF is no fresh faced saloon. 

The XF borrows heavily from the smaller XE and as a result is definitely one of the more dynamically adept options within the executive car class. As such the Jaguar is the more entertaining steer in the class, even bettering the all new BMW 5-series which has historically been the most fun executive car to drive. The BMW is the more rounded machine however, offering a level of refinement and tech the XF just can't match.

Subscribe to evo magazine

Subscribe today to our exclusive new offer and SAVE 39% on the shop price, get evo for its original cover price of £3.00 an issue, plus get a FREE gift worth £20!

With Mercedes’ E Class also having undergone a thorough update in recent years, it now also leads the XF on refinement, powertrains and cockpit technology, although the Jaguar is a more involving drive than the Mercedes. Audi’s A6 isn’t the most thrilling to drive but it’s incredibly competent and its interior is of the highest quality, even if it does lag behind in terms of technology.

The new XF may have its shortcomings, but in the right trim and spec it’s a compelling proposition and a strong alternative to its key rivals from Germany.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Jaguar XF in detail

> Engine, gearbox and technical details - The XF's engine range is made up of four-cylinder petrols and diesels, and a V6 diesel. The supercharged V6 petrol has recently fallen by the wayside, so currently the sportiest option is a 296bhp four-cylinder Ingenium petrol.

> Performance and 0-60 time - No XF is truly fast but the 296bhp petrol and diesel at the top of the range should be quick enough for most, and also deliver their performance with the least fluster.

> Ride and handling - Perhaps the XF's biggest strength; it's more engaging than any conventional, non-super saloon rival.

> MPG and running costs - WLTP changes have taken chunks from the claimed economy figures but those numbers should now be more realistic. Petrol four-pots and the V6 diesel are thirstier and correspondingly more expensive to run.

> Interior and tech - A key downfall in this class, the XF is nowhere near as advanced as the BMW 5-series, tech-laden as the Mercedes-Benz E-Class nor serene as Volvo's lovely S90. The design also leaves much to be desired, lacking any of the imagination or thought we know Jaguar can possess. 

> Design - The XF looks handsome, yet also perhaps is a bit to similar to the smaller XE. Substantial changes have been made though, with the longer body and shorter overhang giving the new car a more dynamic appearance than the old one.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Prices, specs and rivals

For 2019 the Jaguar XF range begins at £33,835 for a 2.0d 161bhp Prestige with rear-wheel drive and a manual gearbox. Moving up to the 178bhp car lifts that to £34,645, while an automatic gearbox adds £2060 to the price of each car and the Sportbrake estate body style by another £2710. R-Sport trim with the entry-level diesel comes in at £35,735 as a saloon, while Portfolio models begin at £39,145 for the 178bhp engine.

Petrol models meanwhile start from £38,100 in 247bhp Prestige trim (and are automatic only) while all-wheel drive adds £1450. Those after a sportier drive may be interested in the 296bhp R-Sport, from £45,015, but sadly the 3-litre supercharged XF S is no longer. You can get a V6 diesel however; a 296bhp Sport starts at a not inconsiderable £52,010 in automatic, saloon form.

Natural Jaguar XF rivals come from Audi (A6)BMW (5 series), and Mercedes-Benz (E Class). All three have been updated or replaced entirely in the last couple of years so all present a strong challenge for the Brit.

If there's one area the XF does still have an advantage it's in its balance of ride and handling. The 5-series and E-class get close, but neither can quite match the natural, fluid feeling of threading the XF down a twisty road. On more open stretches the BMW and Mercedes do feel slightly more restful, but the XF is hardly deficient in this area.

Where the XF's rivals do score is in their choice of powertrains. There's no getting over the XF's four-cylinder units not feeling quite expensive enough for a car in this class, and a drive in one of BMW or Mercedes' straight-six models or an Audi V6 to show you what you're missing. Refinement, for the most part, but also that more intangible sense that money has been spent on the engineering, where it matters.

Those German rivals show up the XF in other ways too. All three have better cabins, being both more imaginatively designed and packing better technology. Audi's dual touchscreen system may not be to all tastes but it works very well once you're used to it, while the E-class's mini-S-class feel makes you wish Jaguar had given its XF more of the larger XJ's character.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Most Popular

Visit/saloons/202421/supersaloon-face-off-old-vs-new
Saloons

BMW M5 F90 vs E28 M5, RS6, E500 and Lotus Carlton: supersaloons old vs new

From the first to the very latest, we take a dive into the history of the supersaloon with the 1985 BMW M5 E28 and other classics taking on today's mo…
4 Apr 2020
Visit/honda/nsx/202424/honda-nsx-review-enough-to-take-on-its-european-rivals
Honda NSX

Honda NSX review - enough to take on its European rivals?

Honda’s supercar is immensely capable and startlingly fast, but it’s easier to respect than it is to love
6 Apr 2020
Visit/aston-martin/dbs-superleggera/22844/new-aston-martin-dbs-superleggera-volante-2020-review
Aston Martin DBS Superleggera

New Aston Martin DBS Superleggera Volante 2020 review

Losing the roof hasn’t compromised the DBS in the way it could have done. It’s a great mix of GT and supercar, with truly spectacular performance.
7 Apr 2020
Visit/features/22907/hyundai-i30-fastback-n-versus-the-col-de-turini
Hyundai i30 N hatchback

Hyundai i30 Fastback N versus the Col de Turini

We take the Hyundai i30 Fastback N up the Col de Turini, a 31km stage of the Monte Carlo World Rally Championship
19 Jul 2019