BMW 5-series review - is this the best saloon in the world?

BMW's most complete 5-series ever, there are almost no compromises in this exceptional executive.

Evo rating
  • Where to start? Powertrains, supremely competent handling and exceptional build quality
  • Feels big on the road, drab styling.

For decades the BMW 5 Series has ruled the executive car roost - and the latest G30 version is no exception. Almost as big and refined and a 7 Series, but with more than a dash of driver involvement, the capable four-door saloon still remains relevant, despite operating in a sea of upmarket SUVs.

Built on the same light and strong platform as the 7 Series (but without that car's expensive Carbon Core), the BMW 5-series offers a range of petrol, diesel and plug-in hybrid engine options, and will also forms the basis for the fire-breathing M5 super saloon. But the new 5-series doesn’t have the executive sector to itself, so can it fight off the best in premium business class – namely the Audi A6, Mercedes E-class and Jaguar XF?

Subscribe to evo magazine

Subscribe today to have every issue of evo delivered straight to you. You'll SAVE 39% on the shop price, and get evo for its original cover price for a whole year!

Available in saloon and Touring estate guise, the 5-series can’t offer quite the breadth of bodystyle choice now that the controversial 5-series GT has been dropped. That curious hatcback model’s demise is only in name, though, as a new 6-series GT has been released to replace it.

BMW 5-series: in detail

  • Performance and 0-62mph time > The cooking G30 5-series could well offer the most capable engine range in the business. All of them are generally at or near the best in class performance wise.
  • Engine and gearbox > Engine ranges are limited at this stage to four and six-cylinder petrol and diesel options. These are all now exclusively connected to an 8-speed ZF sourced automatic gearbox.
  • Ride and Handling > Always a dynamic benchmark in the class, the G30 builds on the previous model’s talents, while continuing to improve on comfort and refinement.  
  • MPG and running costs > BMW is very close to having its cake and eating it too with the diesels, with impressive MPG despite the heady performance they offer. Petrol cars are thirstier, but still offer impressive MPG compared to rivals. 
  • Interior and tech > The interior may not immediately look different to other large BMW models, but step inside and you’ll soon notice the excellent built quality and impressive standard kit on all models.
  • Design > Possibly the most disappointing part of the 5-series, the saloon fails to look immediately distinguishable from its predecessor and has some surprisingly awkward angles.
Advertisement - Article continues below

Prices, specs and rivals: 

The BMW 5-series starts at a tad over £37k for an entry-level 520d with rear-wheel drive. Unlike with the previous F10 5-series though, BMW has kept the variations relatively simple, dropping the Luxury, Modern and Sport trims and now just offering SE and M Sport options. For now, the entry-level petrol option is the 530i starting at just under £41k, meanwhile the six-cylinder 530d and 540i are £45k and £48k respectively. BMW will also sell you a 530e iPerformance plug-in hybrid for just under £45k. 

If you want a 5-series with sportier overtones, M Sport variants are between £3770 and £4295 on top of the SE’s price, while xDrive all-wheel drive is an option on both diesels for an extra £2k. Aside from tiddly 17-inch wheels, standard equipment is impressive with LED headlights, leather upholstery, dual-zone climate control and BMW’s crisp 10.25-inch display connected to the latest iDrive infotainment system all standard.

The most efficient way of building on the equipment level is via BMW’s option packages, each bundling together a combination of features that take the 5-series from being well endowed to positively dripping with tech. Burrow further into the options list and you will find a faintly preposterous range of toys, including a £3750 Bowers and Wilkins sound system, massaging seats, remote control parking and a Driving Assistance Plus system which reaches level 2 autonomous driving - that is the ability to take over in two functions ie steering and throttle in a traffic jam.

In the executive class though, the BMW does not have the playing field to itself. Mercedes-Benz moved the goal posts further than ever with its latest E-class, presenting the class with a true luxury car in (relative) miniature. The E-class has a more spacious and technologically advanced looking interior, but lacks the BMW’s driving finesse. Jaguar’s XF is arguably a better handling option than the new 5-series, but is worlds away from the BMW and Mercedes-Benz when it comes to interior ambiance and general refinement.

The Volvo S90 is now also a rival to be taken into consideration, possibly being the best looking and most serene executive option available, but like the Mercedes is not quite as talented where dynamics are concerned. Audi’s A6 is also well outclassed by the BMW, although an all-new model is now close away and will likely challenge the 5-series for class honours when it arrives early in 2018.

Overall, the 5-series functions in much the same way as it’s predecessors did, offering a brilliant compromise between driving pleasure and overall saloon car excellence regardless of engine or spec. The Touring model shares all the good stuff with the saloon too, but does so with a bigger, pooch worthy carrying capability.


More on 5 Series saloon

BMW 5 Series saloon

2020 BMW 5-series teased in official image

The BMW 5-series is about to get a fresh look, without those bigger kidney grilles...
26 May 2020
BMW 5 Series saloon

AC Schnitzer BMW M550i xDrive review – can upgrades turn the M550i from cruiser to bruiser?

AC Schnitzer’s upgrades come close to turning the M550i xDrive into an M5 rival, but not for UK buyers…
3 Jan 2018
BMW 5 Series saloon

BMW 530e iPerformance review - hybrid exec aims to please both heart and wallet

An effective and clever executive car, but no sports saloon
27 Apr 2017
BMW 5 Series saloon

BMW 520d M Sport review - Entry-level Five is still deeply impressive

If the only 5-series you're able to run is the 2-litre diesel, you won't feel too short changed - it's still an excellent car
17 Feb 2017
BMW 5 Series saloon

BMW 540i review - Petrol 'six plays second fiddle to the diesel

Swift, superbly refined and thoroughly advanced it may be, but this isn’t the pick of BMW’s excellent new 5-series range so far
19 Dec 2016
BMW 5 Series saloon

BMW 530d xDrive review - An astoundingly capable car

A brilliantly resolved car; puts the sparkle back into the 5-series while offering terrific comfort, tech and refinement
7 Dec 2016
BMW 5 Series saloon

(F10) BMW 5 Series review - (2010-2016)

BMW’s 5 Series: so good, it’s all the car you’d ever need
5 Jul 2016
BMW 5 Series saloon

(F10) BMW 5 Series review - (2010-2016)

BMW’s 5 Series: so good, it’s all the car you’d ever need
5 Jul 2016
BMW 5 Series saloon

BMW 530d review - price, specs and 0-60 time

The ultimate executive saloon? Henry Catchpole reports on the new BMW 5-Series
8 Apr 2015
BMW 5 Series saloon

BMW 5-Series Activehybrid review - price, specs and 0-60 time

The first BMW hybrid model to make it to the UK
3 Mar 2015
BMW 5 Series saloon

BMW 520d Efficient Dynamics review - prince, specs and 0-60 time

BMW has boosted economy for the 520d to turn it into the most frugal big exec, with mpg and CO2 to rival a supermini
1 Jan 2015
BMW 5 Series saloon

BMW 535d M Sport review - price, specs and 0-60 time

The new F10 5-Series has failed to capture our hearts so far. Will the 535d M Sport change that?
11 Dec 2014
BMW 5 Series saloon

BMW 535i GT review - price, specs and 0-60 time

Need a car that’s part luxury saloon, part SUV, part coupe? Well, here it is…
9 Dec 2014
BMW 5 Series saloon

BMW 550xD review - price, specs and 0-60 time

The most powerful diesel saloon in the world. evo's John Barker experiences its triple-turbocharged diesel engine for the first time
18 Nov 2014
BMW 5 Series saloon

Autobahns become toll roads from 2015

The German autobahn motorway network could become a toll road for visitors from 2015
14 Jul 2014
BMW 5 Series saloon

BMW M5 30th anniversary model

BMW has launched its most powerful road car ever, to celebrate 30 years of the M5. Pictures and details of the Anniversary model here
7 May 2014
BMW 5 Series saloon

BMW M5 and M6 Horse Edition launched in China

BMW has launched a new Chiies special edition M5 and M6 Gran Coupe, to celebrate the Year of the Horse. Details here
7 Feb 2014
BMW 5 Series saloon

BMW launches M5 and M6 upgrades

BMW has launched a line of retrofit accessories for BMW M5 and M6 models. Details here
15 Oct 2013
BMW 5 Series saloon

BMW M5 E28: iconic cars

It didn’t grab the headlines in its day, but the original E28 M5 set the template for a supersaloon dynasty
2 Jul 2013
BMW 5 Series saloon

BMW M5 2013 update revealed

With the introduction of the revised 5-series, BMW has revealed a new M5, and has confirmed a new Competition package for the M5 and M6
20 May 2013
BMW 5 Series saloon

BMW M5 facelift revealed early

A facelift for the F10 BMW M5 has been revealed early via the company's online configurator
14 May 2013
BMW 5 Series saloon

Porsche Panamera vs BMW M5, Jaguar XFR and Mercedes E63 AMG

evo tests the Porsche Panamera, BMW M5, Mercedes E63 AMG and Jaguar XFR against each other, on road and track, to find the best supersaloon money can …
20 Mar 2013
BMW 5 Series saloon

BMW M5 vs Lotus Carlton

New M5 meets Lotus Carlton, separated by 22 years but united by twin-turbo engines and an appetite for seriously big speeds.
19 Feb 2013
BMW 5 Series saloon

Hartge BMW M5 launched

BMW tuning specialist Hartge has increased the F10 M5's power to 633bhp.
23 Jan 2013