Features

Audi R8 V10 Plus vs Porsche 911 Turbo S - evo Deadly Rivals

Which is quickest on track?

Audi R8 V10 Plus

In terms of all-weather aptitude and day-to-day usability the Porsche 911 Turbo S has generally been in a class of one, but the Audi R8 V10+ has given it a very good run for its money in recent years. The new, second-generation R8 picks up where the previous version left off – it remains a mid-engined, four-wheel drive supercar, but the numbers are more impressive than ever.

Peak power is now 602bhp, which arrives at a spine-tingling 8250rpm. Audi quotes 0-62mph in 3.2 seconds and 205mph flat out. These are figures that promote to the R8 to the supercar big leagues.

The R8 has the dynamic ability to match its straight-line performance, too. It squeezes tremendous grip out of a track surface and the four-wheel drive system very cleverly shuffles torque to where it can be best utilised. The impression you get from behind the wheel of the R8 is that you can drag yourself out of the most ludicrous slides simply by keeping your right foot pinned on the throttle.

>Read our 2015 Audi R8 V10 Plus review

Porsche 911 Turbo S

It’s very well equipped to show the 911 Turbo S the way around a circuit, then, but these Porsches always set mind-bendingly quick times on track. The 911 is down on power – its 552bhp is a full 50 points short of the R8 – but its twin-turbo flat-six delivers massively more torque than the Audi’s normally aspirated V10: 553lb ft plays 413lb ft. Porsche quotes 3.1 seconds to 62mph, which we reckon to be conservative, and a 198mph top speed.

Where the R8 can feel very sharp-edged on circuit the 911 is friendlier and more progressive. It’s like drifting a bear hug. You’ll see in the video how controllable the Turbo S is when it slides.

The Bedford Autodrome was so slick and slippery during this shoot that even with their four-wheel drive system both cars basically skated around the circuit all day long. The rain was on and off – and never particularly heavy – but the track surface just didn’t dry out at all.

>Read our Porsche 911 review

The braking zone for the first corner was particularly treacherous. Lap after lap I’d come around the final corner, cross the start/finish line and brake much earlier than I would in the dry. Every single time, though, I’d have a heart stopping moment as the cars immediately triggered their ABS systems, tyres seemingly finding no purchase whatsoever. It’s amazing how quickly the human brake rationalises the ‘tyre wall or gravel trap’ conundrum in that moment of panic.

I won’t give away the winner now, but I will say the lap times were among the tightest we’ve ever set in a Deadly Rivals shootout.

Recommended

New Porsche Cayman to be electric? The 718’s next steps
Porsche unseen mid-engined concept - side
Porsche

New Porsche Cayman to be electric? The 718’s next steps

Porsche’s mid-engined sports cars could be in for a major shake-up as electric powertrains continues to spread across the range
20 Mar 2021
Porsche collection of dreams stars in RM Sotheby’s February sale
RM Sotheby’s Porsche collection
Porsche

Porsche collection of dreams stars in RM Sotheby’s February sale

From an ultra-exclusive 911 Turbo to a 918 Spyder, RM Sotheby’s Open Roads February sale is host to the Porsche collection of your dreams
24 Feb 2021
Porsche 965 – Dead on arrival
Porsche 965
Porsche

Porsche 965 – Dead on arrival

In the second instalment of our series looking at evo cars that never made production, we spotlight a troubled 911 Turbo successor that fell victim to…
3 Feb 2021
Porsche returning to Le Mans in new 2023 LMDh class
Porsche LMDh racer 2023
Porsche

Porsche returning to Le Mans in new 2023 LMDh class

It’s official. Porsche is in development of a new endurance racer for the incoming 2023 LMDh class
16 Dec 2020

Most Popular

Mercedes-AMG Project One spied on the 'Ring
Mercedes-AMG Project One – quarter
Mercedes

Mercedes-AMG Project One spied on the 'Ring

AMG’s F1-derived hypercar is nearly ready to rival the Valkyrie and T.50
16 Apr 2021
High performance Volkswagen ID GTX models on their way
GTX
Volkswagen

High performance Volkswagen ID GTX models on their way

GTX badge to denote high-performance EVs in VW ID range
16 Apr 2021
All-electric Ferrari confirmed for 2025 reveal
Ferrari badge
Ferrari

All-electric Ferrari confirmed for 2025 reveal

Ferrari has confirmed its first EV, but first three new models are due in the coming months
15 Apr 2021