Skip advert
Advertisement
Features

BMW v Porsche; a contest of brute force against precision – car pictures of the week

Minimalism vs maximalism. That's what pitting the delicate Porsche 911 Carrera T against the anabolic BMW M2 CS feels like. These are our favourite shots from the test

BMW M2 CS v Porsche 911 Carrera T

What’s your preferred flavour of a six-cylinder turbocharged German sports car? Munich or Stuttgart? BMW M or Porsche 911? CS or T? You might question whether BMW’s M2 CS and Porsche's 911 Carrera T are natural rivals. The former is a coupe turned into a sports car, whereas the latter is, let’s face it, the default choice and a ground-up driving machine.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Then you’ll look at the figures and decide that your instinct was right and these are the automotive chalk and cheese. Ignoring the positioning of their 3-litre turbocharged six-cylinder engines, the BMW not only produces more power than the Porsche – 523bhp against ‘only’ 389bhp – but more torque, too: 479lb ft plays 332 lb ft. The M2 CS is also quicker to 62mph, beating the Porsche’s 4.5-second time by 0.7sec. It’s faster too, maxing at 188mph versus 183mph. The only number that’s bigger for the 911 than the M2 CS is the price, with the Carrera T starting at £117,000 whereas the M2 CS starts from £92,475.

What, then, were we thinking of when pitching these two together in the December 2026 issue of evo? As you’d expect, the M2 CS is a bit of a monster that uses its performance advantage to deliver a driving experience that’s big on thrills. The Carrera T meanwhile is, as every generation of 911 has been since the turn of the Century, about finesse, balance and its unwavering ability to take on any road and pretty much win any battle it faces. Steering, damping, body control and brakes have been a benchmark set by the Porsche for as long as many can remember. 

But dismiss the M2 CS at your peril. Yes, it’s a brute but it’s one that’s on your side and one that can be managed and convinced to play to your rules. What it lacks in feedback compared to the 911, it makes up for with a silly sense of humour and the ability to inspire confidence to let you play. A couple of days into our twin-test,, evo’s Deputy Editor James Taylor started to uncover the M car’s talents that brought it closer to the Carrera T’s ability than you'd struggle to envisage.

To read the final verdict and enjoy more of Dean Smith’s marvelous images of the two, you can order a copy of evo December 2026 here.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

Mazda MX-5 (NC, 2005-2015) review – a rear-wheel drive roadster bargain
Mazda MX-5 NC
In-depth reviews

Mazda MX-5 (NC, 2005-2015) review – a rear-wheel drive roadster bargain

It took us a while to warm to Mazda’s third-generation MX-5, but for enthusiasts on a budget it might be the best option of them all
17 Nov 2026
New 2027 BMW M3 electric prototype review – the EV we've all been waiting for
BMW M3 Electric
Reviews

New 2027 BMW M3 electric prototype review – the EV we've all been waiting for

BMW M is more excited about the new electric M3 than it is about the next-generation combustion model. Now we are too...
16 Nov 2026
Porsche 911 Turbo (993, 1995-1998) review – the Turbo’s turning point
Porsche 911 Turbo 993
Reviews

Porsche 911 Turbo (993, 1995-1998) review – the Turbo’s turning point

The 993 Turbo is the last air-cooled, first 4WD Turbo. It's an all-time great and one of the most beloved of the breed
18 Nov 2026