Long term tests

Renaultsport Megane dCi 175

Our diesel Megane's an inspired combination of components. No, really...

This is my sort of car. Yet our silver Mégane has not met with universal approval among you, the readers. It’s a diesel, for heaven’s sake. But so is Audi’s R10 Le Mans winner, so is Peugeot’s 908, so are several other successful racing cars. Diesels have become credible performance engines: their time and their CO2 modesty have come.The best of the new generation of turbocharged petrol engines earn our praise for their near-instant response and massive low-speed pulling ability. Examples? Golf GTI, Mini Cooper S, Mégane R26… And what we’re praising is a thrust delivery akin to that of a good diesel. The Mégane dCi 175 is such a diesel, with effortlessly potent overtaking ability, remarkable refinement and a bit of an aural edge.

Because its pace is so accessible, helped by six slickly selectable forward gears, it’s easy to make the most not only of every progress opportunity on our clogged roads but also of the car’s terrific chassis dynamics. Renault seems to understand what makes a great hot hatchback better than any other car maker, its main French rival (Peugeot) having long since lost its touch. The dCi is true to type, with huge grip and bite, positive and consistent steering and – this is vital – a genuinely absorbent ride. It’s this mix of precision and suppleness that marks it out as a car created by engineers who understand.

Subscribe to evo magazine

Subscribe today to have every issue of evo delivered straight to you. You'll SAVE 39% on the shop price, and get evo for its original cover price for a whole year!

That grip was becoming unreliable in the rain when I took the Renault over, pleased at the prospect of a car able to go almost twice as far as the Mitsubishi Evo X per unit of fuel and give rather greater driver involvement in the process. The front tyres had worn worryingly thin, due no doubt to an excess of trackdays, so new ones were vital. As Continental no longer makes the SportContact 2, we plumped for a whole new set of SportContact 3s.

These were fitted by my local tyre emporium, Discount Tyres of Hemel Hempstead, whose staff have a love and understanding of cars and tyres not always found in the average fast-fit. A slightly bent inner rim was pointed out on one wheel – the victim of a pothole? – so that wheel was fitted on the rear. Had it vibrated we’d have had to replace it, but so far it feels fine. With the wheels off I could get a good look at the Mégane’s ingenious front suspension, too, with its separate hub carrier pivoting on the side of a non-turning strut.

The new tyres got nicely scrubbed-in on a drive to and from Le Mans, the Mégane acting as camera car for the GT40 story in last month’s issue. One of the windscreen’s several chips grew into a major crack on the same trip, though, so that needs to be fixed.

This month, an all-new Mégane appears and our car will be obsolete. There will be Renaultsport versions of the new model, of course. I hope a diesel is amongst them. It’s an inspired combination of components, a combination no other manufacturer has emulated. Why not?

Running Costs

Date acquiredApril 2008
Total mileage13,981
Costs this month£548 (four tyres)
Mileage this month1435
MPG this month37.9

Recommended

Visit/renault/megane/20697/renault-megane-rs-cup-chassis-2020-review-sharp-even-when-you-dont-want-it-to
Renault Megane hatchback

Renault Megane RS cup chassis 2020 review – sharp, even when you don't want it to be

22 Jan 2020

Most Popular

Visit/bmw/1-series/203095/bmw-128ti-revealed-as-direct-hot-hatch-rival-to-vw-golf-gti
BMW 1 Series

BMW 128ti revealed as direct hot hatch rival to VW Golf GTI

BMW has revealed a simplified front-wheel drive hot 1-series called 128ti that will sit below the M135i performance flagship
16 Sep 2020
Visit/nissan/370z/201879/nissan-z-proto-revealed-v6-twin-turbo-six-speed-manual-and-a-catch
Nissan 370Z

Nissan Z Proto revealed – V6 twin-turbo, six-speed manual, and a catch

It’s the Nissan sports car we’ve been waiting 11 years for, but don’t hold your breath for it in the UK
16 Sep 2020
Visit/advice/19675/used-car-deals-of-the-week
Features

Used car deals of the week

We’ve perused the used car pages so you don’t have to. Here’s what caught evo’s fancy this week
16 Sep 2020
Visit/audi/s3/203084/audi-s3-2020-review-the-original-posh-hot-hatch-reformed
Audi S3

Audi S3 2020 review – the original posh hot hatch reformed

Probably the best S3 yet, but still not a class-leading entertainer
15 Sep 2020