Audi RS5 Sportback review - how does it compare to the Mercedes-AMG C63 S?

The first Audi RS5 Sportback might lack the edge of Alfa’s Giulia Quadrifoglio, but its less frantic approach has strong appeal

Evo rating
  • Feels like a junior GT car, refined performer, subtle design
  • Would struggle to keep tabs on an Alfa, M car or AMG rival

It’s taken a while but Audi has finally asked Audi Sport to add its RS ingredients to the A5 Sportback recipe to create this, the new RS5 Sportback. Originally conceived as a peace offering to North American customers who don’t get the RS4 Avant, the RS5’s five-door hatchback body offers some of the Avant’s practicality in a sleeker style. You’ll be pleased to hear it offers all of the über-wagon’s performance, too.

Arriving in the UK to coincide with both the RS5 coupe and RS4’s return from their forced sabbatical from the production line - due to the requirement to modify the 2.9-litre, twin-turbo V6 to comply with the latest WLTP regulations - the RS5 Sportback is an intriguing proposition. 

Subscribe to evo magazine

If you're passionate about the world's greatest performance cars, experience the thrill of driving with evo magazine. Try your first 5 issues for £5.

> New Audi RS4 review – no V8 but plenty to compensate for it

Engine, gearbox and 0-60mph time

It’s not the most charismatic of engines, the 2.9-litre, twin-turbo V6 installed between the RS5 Sportback’s swollen front arches. Many will argue that its 444bhp and 442lb ft of torque mean it is found wanting against rivals from Italy and its home country, and in respects they would be correct. 

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

No matter the engine driving mode selected via Audi Dynamic Select system,  it never feels or sounds like a true thoroughbred. It lacks the fury and thunder of AMG’s V8s, the solid punch of BMW M’s straight-six and the snap and crackle of Alfa’s Ferrari-lite V6. A 0-62mph time of 3.9 seconds suggests it’s no slouch in this RS5 but it’s slow to rev and only really comes alive when the rev counter lights up like a Christmas tree ahead of an upshift. 

Talking of gear changes, the eight-speed S-Tronic gearbox is well matched to the engine’s power and torque delivery with shifts improving noticeably the more aggression you dial in via the driving mode controls. Sadly the gearshift paddles are too small, feel cheap and discourage you from changing gear manually. Though, that’s nothing new among cars with similar setups . 

Technical Highlights

Unlike its rivals, the RS5 features four-wheel drive, Audi Sport’s quattro version rather than the simpler Haldex system. It will send more torque to the rear axle rather than the front, but there’s no option to switch to rear-wheel drive and drift for the cameras. 

Ceramic brakes are an option, 21-inch wheels and tyres are standard and Audi’s Drive Select allows you to modulate engine, gearbox and differential settings, while the damper control allows you to switch between different interpretations of stiffness.

What’s it like to drive?

Approach the RS5 as a Giulia Quadrifoglio rival and you’ll be sorely disappointed. Not only does its engine lack the punch, panache and performance of the Alfa’s but the RS5 clearly hasn’t had the same attention to detail applied to its chassis that the Italian has. The steering lacks sharpness, although in today’s world of hyper alert racks it’s refreshing to have a set-up that’s more considered and linear in its action. It certainly helps the RS5 flow through an apex.

The ferociousness of an AMG V8 is lacking too (for obvious reasons), which means there isn’t the punch out of corners and down straights that you expect from a car wearing these badges and swollen arches. In isolation it feels decently quick when you ask it to get on with it, but it doesn’t have that sternum crushing punch of its rivals when you let it loose. 

Advertisement - Article continues below

Then there is the chassis, which feels a little heavy footed and one-dimensional. Its body is neatly controlled but there is little flowing back to you as you pick your line. The chassis is competent rather than chatty and confidence inspiring, which doesn’t help mask the RS5’s portly 1720kg kerb weight - a figure that can ask just a little too much of the brakes if you find yourself on a road with more hairpins than fourth gear sweepers.

A bit of damp squib then? Compared to the aforementioned rivals yes, but consider the RS5 Sportback as a junior GT car rather than a junior supercar and it comes into its own. 

Knock you approach back to 80 per cent, lighten your grip on its leash and settle into a rhythm that asks less of the chassis, allows the engine to deliver in its preferred mid-range operating window and the whole car strikes up a rapport with you and begins to come into its own. 

For the money you could quite rightly expect the RS5 Sportback to be more competitive against the obvious alternatives, but actually I don’t think it has any clear cut rivals at all. So don’t consider it as an inferior AMG C63 rival, rather consider the RS5 Sportback as a cut price AMG GT 63.

Price and rivals

An RS5 Sportback isn’t cheap, with a price tag of £68,995, although this is partly immaterial in a world where a car’s ownership cost is measured by the monthly payment and not the list price. 

By comparison, Alfa Romeo’s four-door only Giulia Quadrifolgio costs form £69,500, AMG’s C63 saloon from £66,754 and the estate from £65,479 and BMW’s M3 Competition saloon will require £62,905 of your British Pounds. 

Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement

Have You Considered

Visit/hyundai/201854/updated-2020-hyundai-i30-n-spied-before-reveal-early-next-year
Hyundai i30 N

Updated 2020 Hyundai i30 N spied before reveal early next year

16 Oct 2019
Visit/toyota/201837/next-generation-toyota-mirai-revealed-as-hydrogen-flagship
Toyota

Next generation Toyota Mirai revealed as hydrogen flagship

11 Oct 2019
Visit/bmw/201823/bmw-m8-competition-gran-coupe-joins-the-flagship-m-range
BMW 8 Series

BMW M8 Competition Gran Coupe joins the flagship M range

8 Oct 2019
Visit/hyundai/201819/hyundai-i30-fastback-n-versus-the-nurburgring
Hyundai i30 N

Hyundai i30 Fastback N versus the Nurburgring

7 Oct 2019
Advertisement

Most Popular

Visit/porsche/cayman-gt4/201845/porsche-unveils-limited-run-718-cayman-gt4-sports-cup-edition
Porsche Cayman GT4 coupe

Porsche unveils limited-run 718 Cayman GT4 Sports Cup Edition

Special marks the 15th anniversary of ‘Porsche Sports Cup Germany’ race series
14 Oct 2019
Visit/porsche/porsche-taycan/201843/porsche-taycan-4s-revealed-with-up-to-563bhp
Porsche Taycan

Porsche Taycan 4S revealed with up to 563bhp

The mid-range Porsche Taycan 4S expands the brand’s all-electric saloon line-up
14 Oct 2019
Visit/bmw/201850/bmw-design-and-the-sorry-slide-from-quiet-confidence-to-muddled-mediocrity
BMW

'The sorry slide from quiet confidence to muddled mediocrity'

It's contagious. And when you catch it, it's game over. Suddenly you've no idea what's right and good any more
15 Oct 2019
Visit/news/201740/goodyear-eagle-f1-supersport-the-best-by-design
Advertisement Feature

Goodyear Eagle F1 SuperSport: the best by design

That the new Eagle F1 SuperSport range of Ultra Ultra High Performance tyres is taking the trackday market by storm shouldn’t be a surprise – it’s sim…
11 Sep 2019