Features

Best tyres: evo Tyre Test 2015 - Braking and rolling resistance and Aquaplaning

The best performance tyres should make your car faster, safer and more enjoyable. Which should you be fitting?

BRAKING AND ROLLING RESISTANCE

The dry braking test was conducted from 100kph (62mph) and the wet test from 80kph (50mph). This was an objective assessment only, based purely on stopping distances. Generally the correlation between dry and wet results was strong, although, notably, the Dunlop ranked fourth in dry braking, but only seventh in the wet test.

The Continental, Pirelli and Goodyear emerged as joint victors. Despite the Continental’s overall superiority in other wet tests (wet handling, aquaplaning, etc), it finished behind both the Pirelli and the Goodyear in the wet braking test. It did, however, win the dry braking test. Conversely, the Pirelli finished first in the wet and third in the dry, just behind the Goodyear.

Subscribe to evo magazine

evo is 21 and to celebrate, we're returning to 1998 prices! Subscribe now to SAVE 39% on the shop price and get evo for its original cover price of £3.00 an issue, plus get a FREE gift worth £25!

Curiously, the Vredestein – which generally performed strongly throughout the various tests – managed only eighth in both the wet and dry braking assessments. The Toyo brought up the rear in both tests. 

A tyre’s rolling resistance indicates the amount of energy that is required to roll it along the road. High rolling resistance equals reduced fuel economy. This particular test counts for only a very small amount in our final reckoning as we’re much more concerned with outright performance, but for the record the Goodyear scored its only victory here, while the Yokohama ranked in last position.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

DRY BRAKING

TyrePercentage
1Continental100
2Goodyear98.8
3Pirelli98.4
4=Dunlop98.2
4=Michelin98.2
6Yokohama97.7
7Bridgestone96.4
8Vredestein95.1
9Hankook94.4
10Toyo91.1

WET BRAKING

TyrePercentage
1Pirelli100
2Goodyear99.6
3Continental99.3
4Michelin98.5
5Yokohama94.1
6Hankook93.3
7Dunlop92.0
8Vredestein91.9
9Bridgestone89.8
10Toyo81.7

ROLLING RESISTANCE

TyrePercentage
1Goodyear100
2Dunlop92.7
3Hankook90.6
4Toyo90.5
5Michelin84.5
6Bridgestone83.7
7Pirelli81.8
8Continental81.3
9Vredestein80.1
10Yokohama76.0

AQUAPLANING

If you’ve ever hit standing water on a motorway and felt your car twitch, the steering go light and your heart rate rocket, you’ll understand the importance of this test. 

A tyre aquaplanes when it meets more water than its channels can clear at the given velocity. We tested aquaplaning performance both in a straight line and around a gentle curve, with a water depth of 7mm.

The Continental performed best in a straight line, but it was beaten by the Michelin in the curved test. Curiously, however, the Michelin actually ranked last in the straight-line test, behind even the Toyo, which did lose the curved aquaplaning test.

Advertisement - Article continues below

STRAIGHT AQUAPLANING

TyrePercentage
1Continental100
2Dunlop99.1
3Hankook98.8
4Yokohama98.2
5Vredestein98.0
6Goodyear97.9
7Pirelli97.4
8Bridgestone96.5
9Toyo96.0
10Michelin95.5

CURVED AQUAPLANING

TyrePercentage
1Michelin100
2Continental97.5
3Yokohama91.2
4=Goodyear89.0
4=Hankook89.0
6Dunlop87.9
7Pirelli86.2
8Vredestein83.6
9Bridgestone82.8
10Toyo81.3
Advertisement
Advertisement

Most Popular

Visit/toyota/gt-86/202104/toyota-gt86-vs-mazda-mx-5-vs-abarth-124-spider-lightweight-sports-car-shootout
Toyota GT 86

Toyota GT86 vs Mazda MX-5 vs Abarth 124 Spider – lightweight sports car shootout

Three affordable sports cars from Japan and, er, Japan battle it out on the Yorkshire Dales
14 Jan 2020
Visit/sports-cars/202115/porsche-ditches-four-cylinder-for-flat-six-in-cayman-and-boxster-gts
sports cars

Porsche ditches four-cylinder for flat-six in Cayman and Boxster GTS

New models eschew turbos with detuned 4-litre from the Spyder and GT4
15 Jan 2020
Visit/news/202119/2020-geneva-motor-show-preview-what-to-expect-from-europes-most-important-auto-show
News

2020 Geneva motor show preview

Electrification will likely dominate proceedings, but Geneva will have plenty of performance metal to get excited about too
17 Jan 2020
Visit/hyundai/201819/hyundai-i30-fastback-n-versus-the-nurburgring
Hyundai i30 N

Hyundai i30 Fastback N versus the Nurburgring

We brought the Hyundai i30 Fastback back to its spiritual home in Germany's Eifel mountains, where there is a racing track you might well have heard o…
7 Oct 2019