Features

McLaren P1 v McLaren 720S review - in-house rivals battle it out

Does the McLaren 720S have the measure of the mighty P1 hypercar?

I still haven't got used to the raw fury of the McLaren  720S fully winrg-out. I’m not sure I ever will, I;m not sure I ever want to, and I’m not afraid to admit it. Experiencing 8000rpm within the confines of hedges, trees and ditches still evokes a mix of breathless exhilaration, suppressed fear, and a cringing sense of social irresponsibility. In fact, anyone who says they’ve strung together a proper road while dipping regularly into the final 2000rpm on the rev-counter is either some conduit for the spirit of Ronnie Peterson or telling some really big fibs. As you will have gathered if you’ve read the preceding pages, the 720S’s ultimate performance redefines ferocious at anything sub-hypercar level, perhaps even beyond.

It may also have occurred to you that the 720S offers the kind of fireworks that would give the mighty P1, McLaren Automotive’s first Ultimate Series car and spiritual successor to the legendary F1, a very hard time. Indeed, its lap time at Anglesey proves that, in certain situations, it’s faster.

Subscribe to evo magazine

Experience the thrill of driving with evo magazine. Subscribe now and get your first 5 issues for £5 or buy the latest issue in all good newsagents!

> McLaren 720S review

Shorn of the P1’s hybrid system’s weight penalty and with the benefit of five years’ further car-making experience, the conventionally powered 720S threatens to make the P1 seem over-complicated and over-the-hill. Is this a case of early adopters paying handsomely (£866,000 in the case of the P1) for the futuristic tech, only to see those who waited longer getting similar performance for a quarter of the money? I’ll admit, that was what I thought – before McLaren offered the chance to drive a P1.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

What is it about the P1’s demeanour, I wonder, that has the ability to command everything in its orbit? I think it might be the relationship between the turret-like occupant pod and bodywork so pared-back that it’s almost non-existent: less recognisably car, more alien inter-galactic craft. The 720S metaphorically shrivels ever-so-slightly, slipping into the background in suitable deference to its illustrious father.

After the soft-touch thunk of the 720’s door closing, the crack as I slam the P1’s door overly hard makes me wince. Once inside it’s recognisably McLaren, but there’s a lot less trimming and much more structural carbonfibre on show. There’s nothing like the 720’s rearward vision, either, but in an odd sort of way I don’t mind that: I don’t want my £2m-plus (at current market values) hypercar experience to be too friendly, too easy, too accessible.

> McLaren P1 review

The P1’s V8 may be smaller than the fundamentally similar engine in the 720S, but it has more power (727bhp to 710bhp) and it is, of course, further boosted by its 176bhp electric motor. At its peak that makes 903bhp, a figure so massive that I’m not sure I can begin to imagine what it might feel like.

You can tell a lot about a car in the first 50 metres, and the P1 feels firm but poised, reassuringly rigid but also unfiltered in refinement terms – every bit of gravel on the road can be heard and felt, but not in an uncomfortable way. And it is patently very, very angry.

To be honest, I had a preconception about the P1. I knew it would be fast and clever but, as with other hypercars, I always questioned its relevance beyond introducing new technology. Surely its limits were just ludicrously high for the public road. Frankly, what was the point?

Advertisement - Article continues below

> McLaren Senna

I was wrong though, very wrong, because the P1 is by several degrees of magnitude more exciting than the 720S. Indeed, it is one of the most exciting cars I’ve ever driven, period. Furthermore, this isn’t an experience defined by raw speed. There’s a purity to the way the P1 handles and feels – the way it pivots beneath you, the lack of slack absolutely anywhere in its make-up, its nimbleness in spite of its weight. Ludicrous expressions like ‘an Elise with a nuclear reactor on board’ spring to mind. It’s the sort of car you’d take out just to pop to the shops to buy milk. I never expected that.

But the really special thing about the P1 is its combination of almost incomprehensible power, freakishly immediate throttle response due to the electric torque-fill, and the colossal wheeze of the giant turbochargers. In fact, the only thing louder than the P1’s turbos is the sound of my hysterical laughter every time they huff. Embarrassing but true.

Jumping back into the 720S afterwards feels, rather absurdly, like an anti-climax. I must have driven over 2000 miles now in McLaren’s latest supercar and I happen to think the car is a genuine triumph, but, be in no doubt, it’s no cut- price P1. Not by a long shot.

Advertisement

Recommended

Visit/mclaren/201626/mclaren-elva-revealed-new-open-top-speedster-adds-to-top-tier-ultimate-series
McLaren

McLaren Elva revealed – new open-top speedster adds to top-tier Ultimate Series

13 Nov 2019
Visit/mclaren/18541/mclaren-speedtail-real-world-testing-commences-for-fastest-ever-mclaren
McLaren

McLaren Speedtail - everything you need to know about the F1's real successor

1 Nov 2019
Visit/mclaren/201759/new-mclaren-gt-review-woking-muscles-in-on-aston-martins-home-ground
McLaren

New McLaren GT review – Woking muscles-in on Aston Martin’s home ground

17 Sep 2019
Visit/mclaren/201671/new-mclaren-750lt-spied-2017-ecoty-winner-to-get-the-long-tail-treatment
McLaren

New McLaren 750LT spied - 2017 eCoty winner to get the Long Tail treatment

30 Aug 2019
Advertisement

Most Popular

Visit/porsche/911/201958/porsche-911-gt3-vs-gt3-rs-vs-gt2-rs-track-battle
Porsche 911

Porsche 911 GT3 vs GT3 RS vs GT2 RS - track battle

Porsche’s GT3, GT3 RS and GT2 RS are the most hardcore of the 911 breed, but pitched head‑to‑head which will we crown champion?
15 Nov 2019
Visit/buying-advice/19675/used-car-deals-of-the-week
used cars

Best used cars for sale this week

We’ve delved into the classifieds and chosen our favourite cars for sale this week
15 Nov 2019
Visit/ferrari/201950/new-ferrari-roma-612bhp-198mph-gt-car-joins-the-range
Ferrari

New Ferrari Roma: 612bhp, 198mph GT car joins the range

Ferrari has expanded its GT car range with the V8 powered Ferrari Roma
14 Nov 2019
Visit/hyundai/201819/hyundai-i30-fastback-n-versus-the-nurburgring
Hyundai i30 N

Hyundai i30 Fastback N versus the Nurburgring

We brought the Hyundai i30 Fastback back to its spiritual home in Germany's Eifel mountains, where there is a racing track you might well have heard o…
7 Oct 2019