Mazda 6 MPS v Subaru Impreza WRX STI Spec D: Stealth Fighters

Both conceal turbocharged power and 4wd, but which is the better drive, Mazda 6 MPS or Subaru Impreza WRX STI Spec D?

Tarmac wet from a long night of rain, morning skies promisingly bright and clear, and twenty miles of my favourite local B-road stretching out between me and a breakfast rendezvous with photographer Kenny P. It’s the perfect prelude for a memorable cross-country charge in the Subaru Impreza WRX STI Spec D.

With ‘D’ standing for discreet, this is a new take on the STI theme, but a welcome return to familiar territory for fans of the original stealthy-fast Impreza. Sporting clipped wings and muted colours, this STI is no less ballistic than its extrovert brethren, but driving it as Subaru Tecnica International’s engineers intended now no longer feels like a two-fingered salute to other road users. Better still, that toned-down exterior really does reduce your expectations, softening you up for the perfect sucker punch as you discover its 2.5-litre flat-four heart still beats with classic STI fire and brimstone.

Subscribe to evo magazine

Experience the thrill of driving with evo magazine. Subscribe now and get your first 5 issues for £5 or buy the latest issue in all good newsagents!

Despite the steely hue and minimal aerodynamic appendages, the Spec D still has presence, the bonnet scoop, frowning nose and subtly flared arches holding great promise. But then after so many years of WRC exposure, the Impreza’s outline, no matter how discreetly adorned, always suggests performance.

This much is proved as I arrive at our breakfast meeting point and park next to the Mazda 6 MPS. Not so much stealthy as completely off the performance radar, this bulky, frumpy four-door is about as uninspiring as it gets. A quick visual scan reveals little to generate even a flicker of excitement, save the fat oval tailpipes, a closer inspection of which exposes them as nothing more than false finishers, poorly concealing a pair of frankly embarrassing pea-shooters.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Fake pipes apart, if you’re a Q-car purist, you’ll regard the MPS as a masterpiece of deception, for beneath its Clark Kent exterior sits a turbocharged 256bhp, 280lb ft engine, a six-speed gearbox and an all-wheel-drive chassis. On second thoughts, forget the Superman analogy; this car is so unassuming that it resolutely wears its pants on the inside of its trousers at all times. With a vest. Tucked in, of course.

Frumpy it may be, but there’s no denying its specs appeal. Mazda’s first direct-injection petrol engine, the blown 2.3-litre four-cylinder is potent enough to power the MPS to 60mph in less than 6.5sec and on to a serious 149mph. A clever four-wheel-drive system – which works as front-wheel drive until its sophisticated raft of sensors detect help is needed from the rear – can send as much as 50 per cent of drive to the back, as well as switching between Normal, Sport and Stability programs without you knowing – or feeling, for that matter.

Further proof that Mazda is serious about its MPS brand can be found in the fact that the bodyshell has over 50 per cent more torsional rigidity than the standard 6, which in turn has enabled Mazda’s engineers to fit thicker anti-roll bars and suspension that’s stiffer by some 25 per cent at the front and 26 per cent at the rear.

Compare this with the Impreza Spec D’s stats and it’s clear that the covert STI isn’t going to have things all its own way. Boasting a slight capacity advantage, its turbocharged 2.5-litre flat-four develops more power and torque (276bhp and 289lb ft), but needs more revs to hit the peaks. It counters with less weight, tipping the scales at 1495kg (compared with 1665kg for the more portly Mazda), which helps it record an impressive 0-60mph time of 5.3sec, and a top speed of 158mph.

That might look like a sizeable advantage in black-and-white, but on the road, where you’re concerned with shades of grey, it’s unlikely to prove as clear-cut. Factor-in the MPS’s £4500 price advantage and the battle couldn’t be more closely fought. Time to let them slug it out.

The Spec D may look like a more humble Impreza, but the driving experience is pure STI. Fist-tight ride, rifle-bolt gearshift, weighty steering and spiky power delivery make it a full-on, no-nonsense machine from the moment you set off.

Advertisement - Article continues below

As ever with an Impreza, all good intentions of driving at a steady, modest pace go straight out of the window as soon as a derestriction sign hoves into view, your soul corrupted by the STI’s appetite for speed.

Unleashed, the Spec D is quick. Truly, stupidly quick, possessing all the point-to-point pace you could ever want and more than you can sensibly deploy for more than a few minutes without fearing for your licence.

It’s demanding though, both physically and mentally, for the at-times-punishing ride filters few of the road’s bumps, while the power delivery, special Bridgestone rubber and direct steering often conspire to send spasms of torque-steer through your forearms out of tight corners and over awkward cambers. Rapid it may be, but you have to be prepared to roll up your sleeves and get stuck in.

The STI has an adjustable centre differential, called Driver’s Control Centre Differential (DCCD). You can set it manually, but to be honest you don’t really need to switch it out of automatic mode, for the handling and balance is adjustable enough using conventional means. A lift on turn-in shifts the weight nicely forward, and if you get back on the power early enough you can feel the power shifting to the rear, neutralising the modest understeer and even generating some power oversteer when you hit the sweet spot. It’s all easily exploitable in the dry, but if the surface is damp or wet you need to be prepared for rapid corrective steering inputs to catch the tail. Tricky to master, it’s nonetheless one of the most exciting and thrilling all-wheel-drive chassis around.

The brakes are similarly businesslike, the big Brembo set-up providing a rock-hard pedal and plenty of lasting, brick-wall stopping power. You just need to have confidence during the initial phase, for the pedal effort required is reminiscent of an old-school unservoed system.

Censored on the outside, there’s no doubt the Spec D remains a hardcore machine at heart. In contrast, the MPS’s mild manners are shot through the entire car. The steering and other major controls are lighter, more filtered, the gearshift less mechanical, the ride more rounded and compliant. It feels, unsurprisingly, like a workaday saloon.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Don’t be fooled, for while the Mazda is a more relaxed, less demanding car to drive, it still has plenty of pace. In fact, unless the STI’s driver is prepared to throw caution to the wind, the MPS has most of its moves covered. With a more compliant chassis and a less fierce power delivery, the MPS makes subtle but relentless progress, flowing smoothly on roads that have you gritting your teeth and tightening your grip on the wheel in the Spec D. True, there’s less sense of connection, but at times this works in the Mazda’s favour.

Through fast and slow corners it behaves more conventionally than the Impreza, pushing into understeer through tight bends, floating slightly through fast sweepers. Like the Subaru, you can adjust its attitude by playing with the throttle, but it always feels, and behaves, like a front-driver rather than a four-wheel-drive car, albeit a front-driver with excellent traction from apex to exit.

Much like the chassis and power delivery, the brakes have a softer feel and less outright bite, but once you get used to the more mainstream feel you find they are still up to the MPS’s considerable demands. It all adds up to an impressively effective car, but one that isn’t as engaging, exciting or absorbing to drive hard..

Before we started, this comparison didn’t feel strictly fair. After all, the Impreza is a more focused, more expensive and more powerful hardline saloon; a purebred rally-rep rather than a hotted-up repmobile. And much of what we’ve found bears out that initial gut feeling, for the Mazda isn’t as quick all-out, or as exciting to master, and it looks like Valium on wheels inside and out. And yet, the more you drive it, the more you come to realise that it is more than capable of embarrassing many a ‘sporting’ car..

At just under £24K it represents strong value for the performance on offer, but it’s bereft of the emotional content you’d surely crave from the kind of hardware it contains. Maybe you’d be tempted if you could sneak it through on your company car scheme, but it’s hard to imagine actually stumping-up your own hard-earned cash to buy one.

So the Impreza wins, largely by dint of its more visceral performance, but also because it has retained a modicum of visual presence. It’s not without its problems though, the main one being a £28,540 asking price. That’s pricey, especially when it puts what remains a rather tinny Japanese saloon into BMW 330i territory. But unfortunately for Mazda, even if the Spec D’s asking price is too rich for your blood, there’s its equally subtle brother, the humble WRX, to consider. A whole £3K cheaper than the MPS, the WRX couples the Mazda’s pliancy with more character and very similar performance. What’s more, spend some of that saving on the PPP performance upgrade and the WRX steals the performance advantage too.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Clearly, when it comes to this covert breed of mystery machine, Subaru has all the answers.

Comparison

 Mazda 6 MPSSubaru Impreza Sti
EngineIn-line 4-cylinderFlat 4-cylinder
LocationFront, transverseFront, longitudinal
Displacement2261cc2457cc
Bore x stroke87.5 x 94mm99.5 x 79mm
Cylinder blockAluminium alloyAluminium alloy
Cylinder headAluminium alloy, dohc, four valves per cylinder, S-VTAluminium alloy, dohc, four valves per cylinder, AVCS
Fuel and ignitionElectronic engine management, multi-point fuel injection, turboElectronic engine management, multi-point fuel injection, turbo
Max power256bhp @ 5500rpm276bhp @ 6000rpm
Max torque280lb ft @ 3000rpm289lb ft @ 4000rpm
TransmissionSix-speed manual, Active Torque Split four-wheel drive, rear lsd, DSCSix-speed manual; four-wheel drive; front, rear & centre lsd; yaw-rate & lat g sensors
Front suspensionDouble wishbones, coil springs, dampers, anti-roll barMacPherson struts, coil springs, anti-roll bar
Rear suspensionMulti-link, coil springs, dampers, anti-roll barStruts, trailing arms, dual link, anti-roll bar
Brakes320mm ventilated front discs,Ventilated discs, 330mm front, 305mm rear, ABS, EBD
Weight (kerb)1665kg1495kg
Power-to-weight144bhp/ton188bhp/ton
0-60mph6.5sec (claimed)5.3sec (claimed)
Max speed149mph (claimed)158mph (claimed)
Basic price£23,950£28,540
evo Rating (max 5)44.5
Advertisement
Advertisement

Most Popular

Visit/ferrari/201950/new-ferrari-roma-612bhp-198mph-gt-car-joins-the-range
Ferrari

New Ferrari Roma: 612bhp, 198mph GT car joins the range

Ferrari has expanded its GT car range with the V8 powered Ferrari Roma
14 Nov 2019
Visit/mclaren/201626/mclaren-elva-revealed-new-open-top-speedster-adds-to-top-tier-ultimate-series
McLaren

McLaren Elva revealed – new open-top speedster adds to top-tier Ultimate Series

It’s the lightest McLaren Automotive model yet, packs 803bhp and will cost from just under £1.5m
13 Nov 2019
Visit/maserati/granturismo/201792/maserati-granturismo-zeda-run-out-model-revealed
Maserati GranTurismo

Maserati GranTurismo Zéda run-out model revealed

It’s out with the old, in with the new as the final GranTurismo paves the way for Maserati’s ambitious electrified future
12 Nov 2019
Visit/hyundai/201819/hyundai-i30-fastback-n-versus-the-nurburgring
Hyundai i30 N

Hyundai i30 Fastback N versus the Nurburgring

We brought the Hyundai i30 Fastback back to its spiritual home in Germany's Eifel mountains, where there is a racing track you might well have heard o…
7 Oct 2019