Skip advert
Advertisement

Renault Sport Clio 200 Turbo – the car world's greatest misses

This misguided departure from the French brand’s hot hatch heritage saw the Clio fall from grace

Renault Sport Clio 200 Turbo

'The trouble was,’ said my interviewee, with a charismatically thick French accent and more than a wry smile, ‘we spent all the money on the old car…’

We weren’t meant to be chatting about hot Clios, but our man knew about them better than most – I’d just better not drop him in it here – and the conversation had strayed onto one of the most controversial cars ever to wear the now-defunct Renault Sport badge: the final, turbocharged Clio RS of 2013.

Advertisement - Article continues below

I had always wondered what those on the inside really thought of the 200 Turbo. At the time, Renault said the model was aimed at broadening the market appeal of the firm’s hot hatches, which seemed a dangerous sentiment. Broadening appeal smacks of trying to have one’s cake and eat it, especially so in this case, as the previous Clio RS was a bona fide evo icon, a car whose gunslinger‑esque shadow still looms large over the hot hatch market to this day.

> Renault Sport Mégane R26.R (2008 - 2009): Dieppe's finest hour

What he was really saying was that in the increasingly bean-counter-led modern car industry, the idea of spending a small fortune on a ‘cheap’ car to make it as bespoke as the earlier Clio 197/200 had been was about as welcome as the notion of unveiling one with a turbodiesel lump in the nose. Whoever signed off on the 197 project was either a passionate enthusiast, brave or crazy – or perhaps all three.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

I ran one of the very first 197s as a long-termer and I was besotted with it. Those early cars weren’t perfect, but I simply couldn’t believe what you got for such an entirely reasonable price tag: a screaming naturally aspirated engine producing just shy of 100bhp per litre, those bespoke wide-arch panels, a working rear diffuser. It felt like a little jewel in your hands; I never felt like that about the 200 Turbo.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Let’s be clear: like the subjects of many of these Greatest Misses pieces, the 200 Turbo wasn’t a bad car per se. It was fast, well equipped, covered ground ably, and was far better at long journeys than the old car. If you weren’t really fussed about driving, or cars, it was – and I cringe to say this – an improvement. But that’s not the point, is it?

Although Dickie Meaden was generally positive on the car’s European launch (evo 182), despite misgivings about the engine and auto ’box (no manual was offered), by the time of the UK group test (issue 184) the car slumped to fourth in a five-car test. To quote David Vivian in the conclusion: ‘From hero to zero. It almost makes you want to weep.’ Ouch. The Mk7 Fiesta ST won the test, by the way, and you know how many they went on to sell of those.

The turbocharged Clio did get better. In 2016 the 220 Trophy model offered more power and the firmer Cup chassis as standard, but the essential flavour of the car remained. Arguably the stillborn RS16 version, with its 271bhp Mégane RS drivetrain – manual gearbox included – and chunky arch extensions, could have added some much-needed gloss, but it had to step aside for the imminent Alpine A110. They weren’t allowed to make both, and they surely made the right decision within those imposed restraints.

That new icon arrived soon after, and I, like most, never gave the 200 Turbo another thought.

This story was first featured in evo issue 326.

Skip advert
Advertisement

Recommended

Used Honda Civic Type R (FK2, 2015 - 2017) – the forgotten hardcore Focus RS rival
Honda Civic Type R (FK2)
In-depth reviews

Used Honda Civic Type R (FK2, 2015 - 2017) – the forgotten hardcore Focus RS rival

Honda’s first turbo Type R was hardcore and uncompromising, but deeply satisfying when the stars aligned
18 Feb 2025
Used Volkswagen Golf GTI TCR (2019) review – Mk7’s soft sendoff beats any Mk8
Golf GTI TCR
Reviews

Used Volkswagen Golf GTI TCR (2019) review – Mk7’s soft sendoff beats any Mk8

Quick and composed on road or track, the Golf GTI has talents we miss, even if it didn’t sparkle when new
13 Feb 2025
Renault Sport Clio V6 (2001 - 2005) review: the mid-engined hatchback with a supercar spirit
Renault Clio V6
In-depth reviews

Renault Sport Clio V6 (2001 - 2005) review: the mid-engined hatchback with a supercar spirit

A quarter of a century on, the Clio V6 still seems gloriously bonkers. We discover the truth about its troubled birth – and remind ourselves what it w…
13 Feb 2025
Ford Escort RS Cosworth (1992 - 1996) – history, review and specs of Ford's rally star
Ford Escort RS Cosworth
Reviews

Ford Escort RS Cosworth (1992 - 1996) – history, review and specs of Ford's rally star

It was a poster car for a generation and the ‘Cossie’ now has a cult following
12 Feb 2025
Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

Alpina B3 GT Touring 2025 review – a 190mph alternative to the BMW M3 Touring
Alpina B3 GT Touring
Reviews

Alpina B3 GT Touring 2025 review – a 190mph alternative to the BMW M3 Touring

A swansong for Alpina’s hot 3-series lineup, the B3 GT Touring is a fine and unique alternative to the very best fast estates
16 Feb 2025
Used Porsche 911 (991, 2011 - 2018) review – should you buy the unloved 911?
Porsche 991 Carrera rear
In-depth reviews

Used Porsche 911 (991, 2011 - 2018) review – should you buy the unloved 911?

For better or worse, the 991 was a huge moment of change for the Porsche 911, as it passed the half-century mark. We look back at the black sheep of t…
17 Feb 2025
'Do I crave a manual in a Porsche 911? Absolutely. But in a Nissan GT‑R? No way.'
Porsche 911 ST
Opinion

'Do I crave a manual in a Porsche 911? Absolutely. But in a Nissan GT‑R? No way.'

Jethro is celebrating the shift back to manual gearboxes – with one proviso
15 Feb 2025