Porsche Panamera vs BMW M5, Jaguar XFR and Mercedes E63 AMG - Porsche Panamera vs BMW M5, Jaguar XFR and Mercedes E63 AMG: The verdict

After two hard days on the road, it's time to pick a winner: Porsche Panamera BMW M5, Jaguar XFR or Mercedes E63 AMG? Here's evo's verdict

Porsche Panamera vs BMW M5, Jaguar XFR and Mercedes E63 AMG

All four of these cars are magnificent machines, conceived to devour miles with a minimum of effort, yet engage and entertain when mood demands it. However, least convincing in the supersaloon role, at least in this specification, is the Porsche. We debated whether to include a Panamera Turbo or Turbo S, but the £100K+ entry price ruled it out. The trouble is, true supersaloons need to be ultimates, and in this company the 400bhp Porsche felt out-gunned. The manual gearbox of this press car also, sadly, proved slightly cumbersome.

The XFR is a strange car. It’s a truly handsome machine, even in Constabulary White, but the interior and general detailing is a bit glitzy and cheap compared to the German brands. It has prodigious performance and a beautifully lissom feel on a raggedy road, but struggles to up its game to match the out-and-out performance and tight dynamics of the Benz and BMW. Ultimately greatness eludes it.

Subscribe to evo magazine

Subscribe today to have every issue of evo delivered straight to you. You'll SAVE 39% on the shop price, and get evo for its original cover price for a whole year!

Splitting the bi-turbo Germans initially felt impossible, but the M5 steadily and relentlessly asserted itself. In all areas – with the possible exception of steering feel – the M5 out-points the AMG. Crucially, its ability to subtly adapt and adjust its delivery from imperious motorway mile-eater to ballistic back-road projectile is in another league. It’s an epic experience and a fabulous achievement. M Power strikes back

Most Popular

SSC Tuatara hypercar hits 331mph, making it the world’s fastest production car
News

SSC Tuatara hypercar hits 331mph, making it the world’s fastest production car

Over a decade after SSC last entered the record books, its Tuatara has claimed the title of world’s fastest production car
19 Oct 2020
Hot Cupra Formentor spied testing – with a five-cylinder warble
Cupra

Hot Cupra Formentor spied testing – with a five-cylinder warble

Is Cupra about to get hold of Audi’s brilliant five-cylinder petrol engine?
19 Oct 2020
Alpine to become high-performance Renault offshoot
Alpine

Alpine to become high-performance Renault offshoot

Heated-up Renaults but no A110 replacement for Alpine as it follows in Cupra and Abarth footsteps
21 Oct 2020
Car pictures of the week
Lotus Elise

Car pictures of the week

In this week’s car pictures, from issue 279, we look at the highlights from our lightweight sports car triple test
23 Oct 2020