BMW M235i xDrive Gran Coupe review - enough to take on the Mercedes-AMG CLA35?

Not the best way to spend 37 grand on a new car

Evo rating
  • Steering, chassis, brakes, interior tech
  • The engine, the badge, the looks, the idea

The BMW M235i xDrive Gran Coupe. Sounds like quite a title. Sounds like it could/should be quite some car, especially given that it has a 302bhp engine, four-wheel drive and all sorts of other clever stuff inside to help justify its 37 grand price tag.

So then: is the M235i the business, and does it deliver on that latent potential?

Subscribe to evo magazine

Subscribe today to our exclusive new offer and SAVE 39% on the shop price, get evo for its original cover price of £3.00 an issue, plus get a FREE gift worth £20!

Technical highlights

Essentially the M235i xDrive Gran Coupe is an M135i xDrive but with a touch more architecture at the back, a bigger boot, slightly more rear leg room and a slightly stiffer bodyshell – but also with a slightly softer chassis to go with it. Which means you get the same potent but oddly characterless 2-litre, four cylinder turbo petrol engine from the 135i, and the same part-time four-wheel-drive chassis but with marginally softer suspension settings and, says BMW, a slightly more grown-up dynamic personality as a result. So think of the M235i as a more adult M135i – but with suspiciously weird styling to match.

> BMW M135i 2020 review - BMW goes mainstream with its new Golf R rival

Engine, transmission, 0-60mph time

The M235i’s engine is a hard thing to describe subjectively, so let’s talk about its objective values instead. It’s an in-line four-cylinder unit of 1998cc that features variable valve timing, high-precision fuel injection (as if rival engines might feature poor-precision fuel injection instead?), TwinPower turbo technology – but that’s still one turbo, not two, just to be clear – and double VANOS variable cam timing.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

On paper it produces 302bhp between 5000 and 6250rpm and 332lb ft of torque between 1750 and 4500rpm.

In reality, though, it ain’t no E30 M3 engine, even if its outputs might suggest otherwise. And for the time being maybe we should leave it at that.

The M235i’s gearbox is the same eight-speed Aisin auto with paddles that appears in the M135i hatchback, and in this case it works a treat. To hit 62mph from zero the M235i takes 4.9sec, thanks in part to its all-wheel-drive traction, while the top speed is limited to 155mph.

What’s it like to drive?

Good in many respects, excellent in some, but – overall – pretty disappointing for a car that has an M badge at the beginning of its name. Fair enough, the M235i isn’t a full-blown M-car, and the M2 will continue to exist with a turbocharged six-cylinder engine, says BMW. But quite where that leaves the M235i xDrive GC in the meantime is harder to fathom. Somewhere along the path of the increasingly popular ‘dual income, no kids yet’ one must imagine – because that’s who BMW says this car is squarely aimed at.

Thing is, remove the M from the beginning of the name and it would be much easier to like the way the 235i drives. It steers well, the 4WD chassis is nicely composed, even if it does have a tendency to understeer on throttle (oddly), and the brakes, steering, ride, turn-in etc., are all absolutely just fine. More than fine in many respects. But nothing about the way the 235i goes down the road deserves to have an M badge attached to it. As a result it feels like a car that’s trying to be something it isn’t.

Advertisement - Article continues below

Price and rivals

At 37 and a bit grand the M235i GC has various rivals to compete with, the most obvious of which by far is the Mercedes-AMG CLA. And to be blunt, the AMG thumps the BMW subjectively, even if on paper they are almost indistinguishably close.

Truth is, this is not BMW’s greatest car, not by a long chalk. But unfortunately this is what happens when the marketing folks get first call over the engineers. Which appears to be what’s happening at BMW right now. Then again, it’s never too late to say never again.

Advertisement

Recommended

Visit/renault/9499/renault-5-gt-turbo-review-history-prices-and-specs
Renault

Renault 5 GT Turbo – review, history, prices and specs

1 Apr 2020
Visit/volkswagen/202391/volkswagen-golf-gti-turned-to-380bhp-by-mountune52
Volkswagen Golf GTI

Volkswagen Golf GTI turned to 380bhp by Mountune52 

30 Mar 2020
Visit/mercedes-cla45-amg-hatchback/22953/mercedes-amg-cla-45-s-coupe-uk-review
Mercedes CLA45 AMG hatchback

Mercedes-AMG CLA 45 S coupe UK review

28 Mar 2020
Visit/seat/leon-cupra/202381/335bhp-cupra-leon-competicion-adopts-3d-printed-components
SEAT Leon Cupra

335bhp Cupra Leon Competicion adopts 3D printed components

26 Mar 2020
Advertisement

Most Popular

Visit/saloons/202421/supersaloon-face-off-old-vs-new
Saloons

BMW M5 F90 vs E28 M5, RS6, E500 and Lotus Carlton: supersaloons old vs new

From the first to the very latest, we take a dive into the history of the supersaloon with the 1985 BMW M5 E28 and other classics taking on today's mo…
4 Apr 2020
Visit/koenigsegg/202316/1700bhp-koenigsegg-gemera-four-seat-gt-shown-in-new-images
Koenigsegg

1700bhp Koenigsegg Gemera four-seat GT shown in new images

A mid-engined, plug-in hybrid two-door four seater is Koenigsegg’s vision of the ultimate GT
9 Apr 2020
Visit/honda/nsx/202424/honda-nsx-review-enough-to-take-on-its-european-rivals
Honda NSX

Honda NSX review - enough to take on its European rivals?

Honda’s supercar is immensely capable and startlingly fast, but it’s easier to respect than it is to love
6 Apr 2020
Visit/features/22907/hyundai-i30-fastback-n-versus-the-col-de-turini
Hyundai i30 N hatchback

Hyundai i30 Fastback N versus the Col de Turini

We take the Hyundai i30 Fastback N up the Col de Turini, a 31km stage of the Monte Carlo World Rally Championship
19 Jul 2019