BMW M3 (2005) - BMW M3 checkpoints

What to look out when buying a secondhand BMW M3

CSL owners had the option of buying it without the usual 155mph speed-limiter if they held a race licence. BMW will derestrict current cars, but the ECU has to be sent to Germany and it costs around £600. After complaints from CSL owners, BMW also added a commemorative plaque showing it’s one of a limited edition of 422.  If the plaque is missing, dealers are able to request a replacement.

EngineThe M3’s big engine woe was the failure of the crankshaft big-end bearings. There’s no set time when this might occur – it could be 6000 miles or 60,000. Improvements to the oil supply (filters, pumps, etc) should cure this and have been sorted under warranty, so if you’re buying a pre-June ’03 car check this work has been done. The CSL has had none of these problems.

The power steering reservoir cap in both M3 and CSL can become detached and leak, causing damage to the power-steering and making a mess of the engine bay. This can be cured with Loctite and a jubilee clip on the reservoir mount.

Chipping makes little difference to this engine unless accompanied by extensive reworking of its internals, so best avoid modified cars. Finally, on the CSL check that the induction flap is working and the DME software upgrades are up to date.  

GearboxThere are few problems with the gearbox itself. Most issues concern the SMG system but can be cured by applying an up-to-date software upgrade. There was a recall in 2004 to replace the SMG relay module following premature wear on earlier cars; ensure it’s been carried out. There have also been cases of  clutch-slip on earlier cars. This has been identified as the software not accounting for clutch wear – a software upgrade has rectified this.

SuspensionThere have been cases of premature wear of the front wheel bearings due to the bearings working themselves loose. Make occasional checks for wear and it shouldn’t be a problem. The connecting arm of the front anti-roll bar has been known to come loose and make a loud metallic tapping noise when driven over rough surfaces; a revised part should have been fitted by BMW under warranty.

The CSL uses the same suspension bushes as the M3 and they’re not up to regular track use. After a few thousand miles they can need replacing; they should last much longer with purely road use.

BrakesBMW brakes are reliable but begin to grumble if used hard on the road and wilt after just a few track laps. Most owners upgrade the pads and Pagid’s RS19 Yellow compound is popular. Regular track drivers often fit larger 355mm AP Racing front discs with six-pot callipers.

BodyworkThe nose is susceptible to chips, and high-milers can look tatty if not resprayed. Examine closely for accident damage; the common areas are front and rear quarter panels. It’s common to see cracks appear on the front bumper/spoiler assembly of a CSL following impacts with high kerbs – it costs a painful £2500 to replace. The rails adjacent to the carbonfibre roof can discolour, requiring replacement under warranty.

Wheels and tyresThe 18in alloys aren’t popular yet are better for the ride quality and also reduce tramlining. The 19s are easily kerbed and refurbishment is costly. Several CSLs were supplied with normal M3 19in rims instead of the unique CSL alloys with Michelin Cup tyres. The M3 wheels are narrower than the CSL’s and detract from the second-hand value. BMW dealers were often wrongly informed that the CSL wheels could only be fitted with Michelin Cup tyres; in fact, most owners buy a second set of CSL wheels fitted with a regular tyre for winter use.

The CSL has a huge appetite for Michelin Cups if used on track without the negative camber being adjusted from the -1.25 degree standard factory setting to Michelin’s guideline of -2. Note that there are currently no alternative makes to the Michelin Cup in the CSL’s 19in sizes and therefore prices are non-negotiable.

ExhaustThe CSL is fitted with a unique exhaust system that’s lighter and has thinner walls than the M3’s. Yet many owners still upgrade their exhausts. A performance hike is only achievable, though, by fitting louder, higher-flowing race cats.  

InteriorInteriors generally wear the miles well. There have been a few cases of door handles failing but this should have been fixed under warranty. The carbonfibre panels in the CSL are prone to scratches, but the Alcantara is hard-wearing. 


Layout   Front engine, rear-wheel drive
Engine   3246cc, straight-six
Power   338bhp @ 7900rpm - 355bhp @ 7900rpm (CSL)
Torque   269lb ft @ 5000rpm - 273lb ft @ 4900rpm (CSL)
Suspension frontMacPherson struts, coil springs, anti-roll-bar
Susp. rearmulti-link, coil springs, arb
Tyres   225/45 ZR18 front,  255/40 ZR18 rear, Michelin Pilot Sport - 235/35 ZR19 front, 265/30 ZR19 rear, Michelin Pilot Sport Cup (CSL)
Power/weight   219bhp/ton - 255bhp/ton (CSL)
0-60mph   5.1sec -  4.5sec (CSL)
Top speed   155mph (limited)
Price new   £41,150 - £58,455 (CSL)


BMW M3 Competition 2021 review – still the benchmark performance saloon?
BMW M3 Competition
BMW M3 saloon

BMW M3 Competition 2021 review – still the benchmark performance saloon?

It’s bigger and heavier than before, and is now auto-only. So can it copy the new M4’s trick of still being fun to drive? You bet it can
19 Jun 2021
BMW M3 and M4 lifted to 612bhp by Manhart Performance 
Manhart BMW M3 and M4
BMW M3 saloon

BMW M3 and M4 lifted to 612bhp by Manhart Performance 

German tuner Manhart Performance has extracted more power from BMW’s new M3 and M4
9 Jun 2021
BMW M3 Competition and M4 Competition xDrive models detailed
BMW M3/4 Competition xDrive tracking
BMW M3 saloon

BMW M3 Competition and M4 Competition xDrive models detailed

All-wheel-drive M3/M4 Competitions to arrive in late summer
18 Apr 2021
All-new BMW M3 Competition revealed – UK specs and prices confirmed
BMW M3 saloon
BMW M3 saloon

All-new BMW M3 Competition revealed – UK specs and prices confirmed

This is the all-new BMW M3 Competition saloon which will join the M4 Competition coupe in BMW M’s new M3/4 family
12 Jan 2021

Most Popular

2022 Nissan GT-R model year update revealed
MY22 Nissan GT-R T-spec – front quarter
Nissan GT-R

2022 Nissan GT-R model year update revealed

Two new special editions and the return of some iconic colours are the highlights of the Nissan GT-R’s MY22 update
14 Sep 2021
Tesla Model S Plaid breaks EV Nürburgring record – beats Porsche Taycan Turbo
Tesla Model S Plaid
Tesla Model S

Tesla Model S Plaid breaks EV Nürburgring record – beats Porsche Taycan Turbo

Tesla has now recorded a Nürburgring lap time with its Model S Plaid, if that matters
10 Sep 2021
A dead Ferrari F40 in Switzerland – evo Archive
Ferrari F40
Ferrari F40

A dead Ferrari F40 in Switzerland – evo Archive

The story of a Ferrari F40, a flat battery, Swiss chocolate and sex toys…
7 Sep 2021