Long term tests

VW Golf GTI

Would anyone buy the Golf GT over the GTI, asks Henry Catchpole

The digital readout clicked over to 16,000 as the GTI’s wheels rolled onto the forecourt of Autohaus in Northampton just in time for the Golf’s first service. That’s a lot of miles, but the Golf’s internal computer decides when the car needs to be fettled, and it obviously wasn’t too concerned that we’d done two trackdays and probably more than your average amount of caning along B-roads in that time. Mind you, to date I’ve only needed to top the oil up once.

When I picked the car up later that day (washed and Hoovered) the bill presented to me was the princely sum of £154.38 – that’s less than £10 for every thousand miles. Like a man who struggles with his Fs and Ts, you can’t say fairer than that.

Subscribe to evo magazine

Experience the thrill of driving with evo magazine. Subscribe now and get your first 5 issues for £5 or buy the latest issue in all good newsagents!

I mentioned last month that the tyres had been replaced, and the Michelin Pilot Sport 2s are proving to be very good – slightly quieter on the motorway but with a bit more grip out of the corners than the standard Bridgestones. Just so you know, you won’t be best friends with your local tyre-fitter if you spec Bridgestones – apparently their super-stiff sidewalls make them a right pain to get off.

GTI was swapped for GT for a couple of days this month. The latter’s intriguing turbocharged and supercharged 1.4-litre TSI engine produces 168bhp, 177lb ft and a 0-62mph time of 7.9sec. It’s certainly got poke, and although there’s not the thumping mid-range punch of the GTI, it feels a very long way from the asthmatic 1.4 Golf in which I learnt to drive.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

Like the T-FSI, the TSI engine is very impressive for not behaving like an engine with forced induction, but you find yourself wanting to hear some evidence of all its complicated huffing and puffing. It’s a bit like buying a ‘Hits of the ’90s’ compilation and not having any Spice Girls on it – more refined, but secretly a bit of a let down.

The chassis was perhaps the biggest surprise: well damped, beautifully precise and nothing like the sponge pudding you might expect considering the mk5’s bulk. The wheels look nice but, parking the Eeyore-grey machine opposite a red GTI at Stansted, I do confess to feeling a few pangs of envy. Perhaps some cars can be a little too Q.

The GT TSI costs £2000 less than a GTI, but it’s only one insurance group lower (16 to the GTI’s 17) and fuel consumption isn’t vastly improved (it was only a couple of mpg better than the GTI on motorways and doesn’t exactly sip on B-roads), so I was left wondering two things: if you can afford a GT why wouldn’t you make the small leap to a GTI, and what would my Golf be like if you strapped a supercharger to it…?

Running Costs

Date acquiredSeptember 2005
Total mileage17,548
Costs this month£154.38
Mileage this month789
MPG this month30.6mpg
Advertisement

Recommended

Visit/volkswagen/golf/21122/all-new-volkswagen-golf-revealed-eighth-generation-of-an-icon-reborn
Volkswagen Golf hatchback

All-new Volkswagen Golf revealed – eighth generation of an icon reborn

24 Oct 2019
Visit/toyota/yaris/201932/toyota-yaris-gr-4-hot-hatchback-teased-successor-to-the-grmn-and-a-true-wrc
Toyota Yaris

Toyota Yaris GR-4 hot hatchback teased – successor to the GRMN and a true WRC homologation special

6 Nov 2019
Visit/audi/r8/201931/entry-level-audi-r8-v10-rwd-added-to-the-range
Audi R8

Entry-level Audi R8 V10 RWD added to the range

6 Nov 2019
Advertisement

Most Popular

Visit/alfa-romeo/21322/alfa-romeo-to-launch-new-700bhp-8c-and-600bhp-gtv-coupe
Alfa Romeo

Alfa Romeo culls sports car programme in wake of FCA merger

Italian’s future performance models killed off in favour of more profitable SUVs
11 Nov 2019
Visit/caterham/201924/caterham-620r-v-ariel-atom-35-v-elemental-rp1
Caterham

Caterham 620R v Ariel Atom 3.5 v Elemental Rp1

Flight Club - lightweight track day toys with heavyweight powertrains, Steve Sutcliffe compares them on track at Anglesey circuit in Wales
5 Nov 2019
Visit/toyota/yaris/201932/toyota-yaris-gr-4-hot-hatchback-teased-successor-to-the-grmn-and-a-true-wrc
Toyota Yaris

Toyota Yaris GR-4 hot hatchback teased – successor to the GRMN and a true WRC homologation special

Gazoo Racing to follow up its 2019 WRC championship with an all-new car based on the GR-4 hot hatch
6 Nov 2019
Visit/hyundai/i30-n-hatchback/201775/hyundai-i30-n-versus-hyundai-i30-tcr
Hyundai i30 N hatchback

Hyundai i30 N versus Hyundai i30 TCR

Can Dickie Meaden beat Steve Sutcliffe in a straight(ish) race? We sent them to the Circuit Nuvolari with a pair of Hyundai i30 Ns to find out.
20 Sep 2019