Mini Countryman review - Mini looks, but where's the Mini fun?

Mini’s new SUV has grown up, but it’s lost the Mini fun factor along the way

Evo rating
from £22,465
  • Refined, comfortable, quality cabin, effective all-wheel drive
  • Grown up at the expense of enjoyment, grabby brakes

We can’t expect Mini to build ten-foot-long, era-defining city cars any more, but we do expect the BMW-owned company to turn out cars that are fun to drive and show up their rivals as sloppy, dull and character-free.

Unfortunately, the latest Mini Countryman doesn’t manage that. It’s undoubtedly a more rounded product than its predecessor and makes gains in all the areas you’d expect, from quality, through equipment and safety, to performance and economy. But in making a more mature, refined product, the Countryman moves even further away from the characteristics that until now have allowed even the least-mini Minis to put a smile on your face.

Subscribe to evo magazine

Subscribe today to have every issue of evo delivered straight to you. You'll SAVE 39% on the shop price, and get evo for its original cover price for a whole year!

> Mini Cooper review - retro hot hatch is as fun as ever

And the Countryman is getting expensive. While that’s to be expected, and similarly-sized crossovers stray into similar pricing territory, we can’t help but notice the availability of some proper evo performance favourites for similar money - notably a wide range of hot hatchbacks, most of which are as practical as the jacked-up Countryman but considerably better to drive.

Mini Countryman in detail

> Performance and 0-60 time - Decent on-paper figures, but performance is blunted somewhat by the Countryman’s weight. Cooper S feels disappointingly strained.

> Engine and gearbox - Petrols and diesels, manuals and autos, front- and all-wheel drive. There’s plenty of variety here.

> Ride and handling - The Mini that doesn’t feel like a Mini. Perfectly competent, and rides well, but the fun-factor is slowly being lost.

> MPG and running costs - Diesels are most frugal, but petrols aren’t far behind. All-wheel drive harms the on-paper figures.

> Interior and tech - Better quality than before and all works well, but for some the cabin’s retro look will be a bit too much.

> Design - Some uncomfortable details and proportions. It’s hard to be original when your product lineup has to draw inspiration from a 1959 city car.

Prices, specs and rivals

£22,465 will get you behind the wheel of a Cooper Countryman, provided you stay away from Mini’s extensive options range. All-wheel drive (available on all models) adds £1090 to that figure, while the automatic transmission will set you back £1495.

Next up is the Cooper D at £24,425, while the Cooper S starts at £24,710. To step up to the Cooper SD (auto only) will cost you £27,965, and the John Cooper Works ALL4 begins at £30,675.

It goes without saying that all models are therefore a fair chunk of money, and the equivalent cash would net you plenty of options in the hot hatchback class. For Cooper money you could get a Ford Focus ST, while the JCW is well into Volkswagen Golf R territory.

But let’s assume that only a crossover will do. The new kid on the block is Toyota’s C-HR, whose futuristic styling is a counterpoint to the Mini’s retro vibe and has the nimble handling, precise steering and throttle-adjustability that were all characteristics you might have found in a Mini back in the day. Engine options are unfortunately limited (there’s a 1.2 turbo and a 1.8 hybrid) but it’s a compelling alternative.

The Countryman’s pricing creeps into premium territory, so you might also consider cars like the Audi Q3, BMW X1, Mercedes-Benz GLA and Lexus NX as you stray further up the range.

More on Countryman

Mini Countryman SUV

New MINI Countryman JCW review - is performance micro-SUV a niche too far for MINI?

Potent but pricey new Countryman is too big and heavy to be much fun
11 Apr 2017
Mini Countryman SUV

New Mini Countryman revealed - sporty crossover begins at £22,465

New plug-in hybrid model joins the range for the first time; all-wheel drive available on all models
26 Oct 2016
Mini Countryman SUV

New Mini Countryman to get plug-in hybrid model

Driving fun, as well as efficiency, promised by Mini's first production plug-in hybrid
17 Oct 2016
Mini Countryman SUV

What it's like to drive Mini's ALL4 Racing Dakar-winning car

evo braves the deserts of Dubai to experience just a fraction of the heat and chaos of the Dakar rally
23 Apr 2015
Mini Countryman SUV

Mini Countryman 2014 update

The Mini Countryman has been facelifted for the 2014 model year, with a power boost for the Cooper S model. Details and pictures here
16 Apr 2014
Mini Countryman SUV

Mini Countryman matt paint option priced

The Mini Countryman and Paceman get a new matt paint finish option
23 Oct 2013
Mini Countryman SUV

Mini and Race2Recovery on the Dakar Rally

Despite being one of the world's toughest motorsport events, the Dakar Rally's desert trails can be a great leveller. evo meets the 2013 event's David…
28 May 2013
Mini Countryman SUV

Weekly motorsport update - Dakar latest

Our weekly motorsport update for January 14 focuses on the Dakar Rally and WRC
14 Jan 2013
Mini Countryman SUV

Goodwood FoS: Mini Countryman WRC video

Prepare for the 2012 Goodwood Festival of Speed by watching a Mini Countryman rally car climb the famous hill
28 Jun 2012
Mini Countryman SUV

Video: driving the Mini WRC car

evo's Henry Catchpole gets a unique chance to drive the Mini Countryman WRC in our exclusive video
20 Sep 2011
Mini Countryman SUV

Video: Mini Countryman WRC

Handbrake turns and smoking tyres as Prodrive lets Henry Catchpole drive the new Mini WRC car
5 Sep 2011
Mini Countryman SUV

Mini Paceman concept revealed

Mini reveals a sleeker, three-door Countryman SUV. Meet its Range Rover Evoque rival
19 Dec 2010
Mini Countryman SUV

Mini Countryman Cooper D diesel All4 review

Mini's Countryman SUV reviewed with new diesel engine and four-wheel drive
22 Oct 2010
Mini Countryman SUV

Mini Countryman WRC rally car revealed

Mini's WRC world rally return confirmed with the reveal of Kris Meeke's Prodrive Countryman
1 Oct 2010
Mini Countryman SUV

Mini Countryman Diesel review

Can Mini keep its brand values intact in a diesel off-roader? Harry Metcalfe reports
9 Sep 2010
Mini Countryman SUV

Mini Countryman enters World Rally Championship

Mini will enter the WRC from 2011 with a rallying version of its Countryman SUV
27 Jul 2010
Mini Countryman SUV

Mini Countryman Cooper S ALL4 review

Mini Countryman Cooper S SUV has five doors, new 181bhp engine, optional 4WD
22 Jul 2010
Mini Countryman SUV

Mini Countryman Cooper S ALL4 review

LIVE UPDATES: first drive of Mini's Cooper S SUV, the Countryman. As good as the hatch?
16 Jul 2010
Mini Countryman SUV

Mini Countryman Cooper S ALL4 (2010-2017) review

evo's first drive of Mini's SUV, the Countryman. Is it as fun to drive as a Cooper S hatch?
16 Jul 2010
Mini Countryman SUV

Mini Countryman road test

Has Mini managed to package the things we love about the Cooper S in the high-rise Countryman?
19 May 2010