Find a car review


Porsche 911

The four-wheel-drive 911 is back and it's as brilliant as ever, but is it worth £5K more than a 2wd Carrera?

Evo rating
from £69,900
  • Huge grip, power and composure
  • The £5K cheaper Carrera S

Porsche's new Carrera 4S is brilliant. Sorry to spoil the surprise - if indeed you think Porsche building another life-affirming 911 is a surprise - but it's as simple and as black-and-white as that. The marriage of the indomitable 350bhp, 3.8-litre flat-six Carrera S engine and an updated version of the light and heavily rear-biased all-wheel-drive system from the previous-generation 996 C4S creates a car of spectacular composure and devastating point-to-point speed. By any standards the 997 C4S is a special car. It needs to be. At £69,900 it's £5000 more than its rear-drive sibling, the outrageously competent Carrera S. But although the S lacks the assistance of driven front wheels, it is blessed with Porsche's incredibly effective PSM stability system and enough mechanical grip to rip ruts into dry tarmac: the C4S has its work cut out to make sense in any market that doesn't have snow for six months of the year. Aesthetically the C4S certainly talks-the-talk with a confident, muscular flare of its rear wheelarches. It's 44mm wider across its hips than the rear-drive models (as is the £62,930, 321bhp C4) and in combination with the 997's retro headlights and silhouette the C4S looks even more like a classic 911 road-racer. In fact, the C4S is even wider than the 996 Turbo and the next Turbo will borrow this deliciously swoopy metalwork. So, that's an extra 44mm of voluptuous sheet metal for your money. And, of course, that clever viscous multiple-plate coupling four-wheel-drive system. Under normal circumstances the C4S channels just 5 per cent of its power to the front wheels, but this can rise to as much as 40 per cent when the rear wheels start to slip and the electronics go on the hunt for traction. In theory this should allow the C4S to retain the nimble drive into the corner of the rear-drive coupe (not to mention the unburdened steering feel) and build on the 997's already formidable traction and control on the way out. The system adds just 55kg in weight. As is usually the way with Porsche, if it looks like it will stack up on paper then the engineers will have striven to make the reality even more impressive. And it is. The C4S, like the standard Carrera S, is a car that manages to feel desperately dependent on your input and keen to engage you on every level and yet it's completely trustworthy should you misread the high-definition information being filtered through steering and seat. The PASM suspension smothers nasty roads with disdain, but hit the Sport button and the C4S suddenly gets a real edge; think GT3 that's been to finishing school. That unique rear-engine feel is retained and although the steering has gained weight and lost a degree or two of feel, the C4S is still a precision tool. It rewards commitment and smoothness with its tight gearshift, perfectly placed pedals, fearsome body control and eye-popping stoppers (ceramic discs are a £5349 option, but we suspect you'd rarely notice the benefits). Mechanical grip is phenomenal and, although that howling flat-six has enough grunt to unstick the rear tyres out of very tight turns, it's rare that the PSM system even registers an interest in your efforts. Switch it off, carry in that bit more speed, drive through the mild understeer and eventually you might get the C4S to take some attitude, but almost before you've wound on the opposite lock the front wheels get a slug of power and pull it straight. On the right road it's devastating, and in the wet it should be sensational. Some will suggest that it's too good, too unflappable, and if you get your thrills from easily achieved oversteer the C4S certainly isn't the right car for you. But when you're on a charge, and despite the unfazable poise of the C4S, you feel intimately involved. There's still a tangible sense that you, the driver, are the key ingredient in the mix, working the chassis to its limits, dictating the car's attitude and meticulously balancing power with grip. And you still get that gentle corkscrewing as the huge 305/30 ZR19 rear rubber digs in under the weight and torque of the creamy engine and the steering goes light in your hands. PASM's infinitely adjustable damping has done little to dull the 911's unique character. And should you have the opportunity to drive over and above the limits of the tyres and drivetrain, the C4S remains a beautifully resolved, predictable handler. The laws of physics are obviously no match for Porsche's engineering know-how. It's a winner, then? Well, yes and no. The C4S is an awesomely accomplished device (the first four-wheel-drive 911 to be quicker around the 'Ring - by two seconds - than its rear-drive equivalent), but the standard 997 is so good that I can't quite see the real-world advantage of the C4S. I love it, but I'd get just as much joy from the Carrera S. And, with a 911, that's all that counts.


EngineFlat-6-cyl, 3824cc
Max power350bhp @ 6600rpm
Max torque295lb ft @ 4600rpm
0-604.8sec (claimed)
Top speed179mph (claimed)
On saleNow

Have You Considered

Porsche 911

New Porsche 911 GT3 Touring spied

19 Aug 2019
Porsche 911 Carrera

New 2019 Porsche 911 Carrera S review - road and video track test

15 Aug 2019

Most Popular

Best cars

Best V8 cars past and present – our favourite eights and the cars they’re found in

Whether it’s smooth and sophisticated or motorsport-like in its aggression, the V8 remains one of our favourite engine types, warts and all
20 Sep 2019
Hyundai i30 N hatchback

Hyundai i30 N versus Hyundai i30 TCR

Can Dickie Meaden beat Steve Sutcliffe in a straight(ish) race? We sent them to the Circuit Nuvolari with a pair of Hyundai i30 Ns to find out.
20 Sep 2019
Volkswagen Golf hatchback

Volkswagen Golf Mk8 spied near-free of camouflage before October debut

All-new eighth-generation Golf is only weeks away from its reveal – this is all you need to know.
18 Sep 2019

Goodyear Eagle F1 SuperSport - picked by Porsche

Goodyear has many close associations with premium global car brands, but being asked to develop a trackday tyre for Porsche's extreme 911 GT3 RS was a…
14 Aug 2019